3 Things I'd Change About My Homeschool Experience | #34

Ex-Homeschoolers Club

Ask about Ex-Homeschoolers Club

Episode Description

Join the Newsletter for the latest Ex-Homeschooler News: https://exhsclub.beehiiv.com/subscribe

In this episode of The Ex-Homeschoolers Club, I'm reflecting on a decade of being homeschooled and dive into three specific areas I would approach differently if I had the chance to go back. While I appreciate much of what my parents did, this episode explores critical reflections on my understanding of government, religious curriculum, and emotional boundaries. I also unpack how these elements have impacted my adult life and what I think future homeschoolers can do better. Whether you're a current homeschooler, a curious ex-homeschooler, or just someone interested in education reform, this one's for you.

*Key Takeaways:* - Government Education Matters: I discuss the missed opportunity to deeply understand local and state politics beyond textbooks—through field trips, town hall meetings, and active involvement. - Challenging Religious Narratives: Why I'd encourage exposure to a broader spectrum of belief systems rather than faith-based exclusivity in every subject. - Emotional Boundaries in Education: The crucial need for learning to set boundaries, communicate discomfort, and recognize the importance of emotional well-being from a young age. - The Power of Perspective: Looking back on my homeschool journey offers powerful lessons for educators, parents, and students alike. - Self-Reflection as Growth: Honest retrospection is key to personal development and helps create better systems for the next generation.

*Timestamps* 00:00 Welcome Back to the Ex-Homeschoolers Club 00:35 Reflecting on 10 Years of Homeschooling 01:00 Understanding Government and Politics 03:11 Challenging Religious Curriculum 12:21 The Importance of Emotional Boundaries 16:38 Conclusion and Final Thoughts

If you enjoyed this conversation, be sure to subscribe, leave a review, and share it with a friend who might benefit from hearing this story. Follow Ex-Homeschoolers Club on Instagram and TikTok for updates, and send us a message – we’d love to hear from you!

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/exhsclub/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@exhsclub Email me at [email protected]

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I was homeschooled for 10 years and while most of it I view very positively, there's three main things that I wish
  2. could have been done maybe a little bit differently. Hey, my name is Jacob Gooden and uh if you're new here, this
  3. is the Exhomeschoolers club, the best exhomeschooler podcast this side of the internet. Normally I've got guests on.
  4. We chat about the good, the bad, and the ugly of growing up a homeschool kid. So
  5. if that's you, you're in the right place. Okay. And for anyone who's returning, hey, how's it going? Welcome
  6. back. You heard me right. I'm going to talk about three things that I would do differently in my homeschool experience.
  7. I want to preface with this. I was homeschooled for 10 years from second grade all the way through high school. I
  8. think my parents did a decent job. I think it turned out okay. I'm not the dumbest guy in the room. Also, maybe not
  9. the smartest guy in the room, but I made it. I'm an adult. I'm surviving. We're okay. That being said, I think that
  10. there's three things that if I could go back in time and tell my my parents at a
  11. younger age be like, "Hey, I think maybe do these." These are them. So, number one, I think just a better understanding
  12. of how our country works. And I'm speaking from a United States of America perspective here, but how does our
  13. country work? I sometimes question that dayto-day. And you know, I have a decent
  14. understanding of history, right? I understand how this country came to be. I understand the founding documents. I
  15. understand. I've read all that stuff. I understand there's three branches of government. Like, I get it. I think what
  16. was missing was maybe not so much of the class aspect of like here's how government works. What I think was
  17. missing was seeing how it plays out and affects our day-to-day lives. So for me,
  18. I look at that and I go, I think the missed opportunity was an involvement in local and state
  19. politics. Now, that doesn't mean like I wanted to be governor of California or, you know, even serve in local
  20. government, but I think it would have been really cool to do field trips to state capital. I think it would have
  21. been really fun to meet elected officials, be able to ask them about their job and what they do and how they
  22. vote and how they listen to their constituents. Going to town hall meetings and like learning about what
  23. that looks like and how do we stand up and you know these are our elected officials. We put them in office to
  24. enact the will of the people and we are the people. So, how do we communicate that best to them? And I think it would
  25. have just been really cool to have a lot of those real hands-on experiences, right? And homeschooling is a hands-on
  26. experience. A lot of people cite that as being one of the main reasons they want
  27. to homeschool, right? Is that ability to give their kids like unique experiences.
  28. What better way than like teach them how the the world works. So I think that now
  29. as an adult and getting much more heavily involved in politics and an understanding of how this country works,
  30. I look at it and I go this would have been so easy to accomplish. It's timeconuming obviously but it would have
  31. been the the information is there so to speak. It's just a matter of actually like going and doing it. So that's
  32. number one. Number two is that I would push back on my parents a little bit of involving religion in
  33. every curriculum that we had. Now, I think religion is can be important and for a lot of homeschool families,
  34. religion is like a key proponent of why you homeschool your kids. For the person
  35. I am today, that's not a good enough reason to homeschool your kids is religion solely. But I do understand it,
  36. right? I understand wanting to have a little bit more control over the things that your child is learning. When you
  37. limit everything that you're being taught into a bubble, and religion to some degree is a bubble, you block out
  38. voices that could have compelling arguments. And so for me, I think being able to as as
  39. I've gotten older and being able to explore a more diverse look at the world and ask questions of other religions and
  40. other belief systems and and things like that, it's been very eye opening to kind
  41. of just like feel it out, right, and figure out what I believe on my own. So, let me
  42. give you kind of an example, right? because I can talk hypotheticals all day, but let me give you an example.
  43. Science for a lot of Christian homeschoolers is very Bible- based, right? And so you have this historical
  44. part and this faith-based part, right? And they work together to to reconcile it, right? So we believe in like young
  45. earth. We believe in, you know, literal 7-day creation as a Christian. I'm speaking as a Christian at this at this
  46. point. We believe in things like Noah's ark, right? and Noah's ark being a key catalyst in the laying down of a ton of
  47. fossils that we find today, right? And so I grew up believing all of this and yeah, there was maybe a little bit of an
  48. emphasis on like evolution, but it was always from a standpoint of yeah, but evolution has already been debunked. We
  49. know that that's not true, so kind of don't worry about it. Which creates in itself its own
  50. problems of like evolution is not debunked first and foremost. Um, some people would argue it
  51. is, but but I don't think it is. It's it's a commonly held belief by many people that that's what happened, right?
  52. And so rather than just kind of like pushing it off to the side and saying, "Oh, that's an already debunked theory.
  53. We don't really need to focus too much on it. Here's like an overview of of understanding it." I think that being
  54. able to look at Let's talk about creation. I think being able to look at an account of here's what we here's how
  55. we think the world started, right? from a from a biblical perspective of God spoke it into existence and it was a
  56. literal seven days and he built all of these things in in those days to looking at like an evolutionary perspective and
  57. understanding okay so the big bang like let's talk about that and let's look at the the intricacies of of what would
  58. need to happen to to do that right can we replicate that is that being replicated in other galaxies those types
  59. of questions and then you talk about the evolution of like where do trees come come from? Where does where does human
  60. come from? Where does human come from? Where do humans come from? Another really interesting one, and I learned
  61. more about this when I got to college because I took geology when I was in college. It was a rocky time, uh, if you
  62. will. Um, but I thought one of the most interesting parts about that class was we were discussing how rock layers were
  63. were laid down over time and how to assess the amount of time between rock layers. And
  64. so I grew up believing again the Bible and believing in Noah's arc and the worldwide flood, right? And also
  65. believing that that was a massive catalyst in the world that killed thousands, millions, I don't know, lots
  66. of living beings and they were, you know, buried underwater and under soil and and things like that, right? And so
  67. when we are looking at like the fossils and we're looking for fossils, we can find stuff from that time. And then I
  68. took this geology class and like I said it was it was interesting to talk about the length of time and understanding how
  69. if you've ever looked at a rock structure. Let's talk about the Grand Canyon. Like if you've ever been to the
  70. Grand Canyon, you look at the Grand Canyon, it's like all these lines up the Grand Canyon. And it's really
  71. fascinating how it's time, right? It's a symbol of time that's going up. And so to look at the opposition of
  72. Christianity, which you know is that these layers get laid down over thousands, hundreds, thousands, millions
  73. of years, things get trapped inside of them. And what that means, right? And how do things get trapped inside of
  74. them? Sometimes it's quickly by rushing water. Sometimes it's slow by dying out in the wilderness and rotting away. And
  75. then, you know, over time just dust blows and, you know, maybe some waters come through and whatever else. But that
  76. diversity of like thinking I thought was really interesting. And again, I went to
  77. a Christian college, so a lot of this still steeped in religion when it comes to the
  78. sciences, but starting to ask those questions of like, well, what if, you know, and some people would argue those
  79. are really dangerous. Is it really dangerous to ask questions? I don't think so. I think it's I personally
  80. think it's really fun because it pushes you to find answers, right? And the strongest argument I always hear for
  81. faith is that well at some point you just got to believe, right? You just got to take a
  82. leap of faith, so to speak. And this episode is not meant to be, you know, sway you on
  83. religion or anything like that, but I just I always find it interesting because uh in conversations I have with
  84. friends who are still believers and still believe in like literal 7-day creationism and young earth theory and
  85. things like that. It's always interesting because they get we get to a point in the conversation where
  86. sometimes they just go, "Well, okay, but at some point you just got to like have
  87. faith that this is what it is." And ultimately, yeah, I understand. like I also have to have faith that in whatever
  88. I believe of like how did the world really start? So anyway, the reason I bring this up as a point that I would
  89. change in my curriculum is not so much of being like, oh well now I'm not a Christian and I wish that my parents had
  90. given me the knowledge beforehand. No, I I bring it up because initially when I was presented with these
  91. ideas, they became really good talking points for me to like discuss and ask questions about. And I think that that
  92. was so much lacking in my my curriculum growing up of everything was faith-based
  93. from science to English to math to just everything was just had this layer of Christianity in it. Once I stepped
  94. outside of that and I started to be able to ask questions about other religions.
  95. I loved Greek mythology growing up. But it was just that. It was mythology. It was a storytelling mechanism, right? And
  96. it was an explanation as to why the world was the way it was. Why did it thunder? Oh, well, it must have been
  97. Zeus, right? And what happens when you die? Well, you go to the underworld and there's u Hades, right? And I loved
  98. Greek mythology because I looked at it as this kind of an explainer of the world before we
  99. had modern day science. As humans, we put these characters, so to speak, and on these pedestals to look at. But I was
  100. never I never really understood why we didn't actually look at it from the perspective of there were
  101. people who fully believed this who were dedicated to this type of religion. Why was that? What led them to
  102. that? And so I think just the diversity aspect of it would have been really cool
  103. to understand argue modern day religion. Why do Buddhists believe what they believe? Why do Mormons believe what
  104. they believe? How is it really all that different? And less so from a combative spo space. Um because I think maybe
  105. that's more what I have the the issue with is the combative place of religion in our
  106. curriculums where it was always Christianity is right 100% of the time. All other religions are fake. And so you
  107. go into it with a jaded knowledge that all other religions are already fake. So, I don't really h they hold no
  108. authority over me. And I I don't know. I just think it's an interesting thing if
  109. you can teach somebody to maybe put that opposite thinking on temporarily to be like, "Okay, what would it take for me
  110. to actually believe this other thing?" Maybe that's more what I'm getting at. So, you could disagree with me. That's
  111. fine. I'm totally down for that. And this again is some dude on the internet just sharing his thoughts of what he
  112. would change about his homeschool experience. The la the last point I wanted to talk about was less from an
  113. education perspective in the traditional sense of like a curriculum and more from
  114. like an emotions and psychological perspective and that was I think that my parents could have done a better job of
  115. teaching me boundaries. My homeschooling experience was I'm not going to say unique. I think
  116. everybody's is unique. There was four of us that lived in that house and two of us were homeschooled and two of us were
  117. the adults. None of us I think were super emotionally healthy people. And so I don't hold anything against my
  118. parents. I think they did the best they could with what they were given. And what's cool is now as we've gotten older
  119. and we've become much more emotionally healthy, I think we are just in better places with each other to some degree or
  120. we understand ourselves better, maybe know how to communicate it better. So I want to kind of preface with that. But
  121. boundaries for me is something that is one of my big focuses for 2025. And as I've been working on it and
  122. learning the power of no and and things like that, I keep getting reminded of experiences from when I was a kid. And
  123. when I was in high school and junior high, one of my friends dads was just like a very hugging person. He was very
  124. like he just liked hugs. And that doesn't necessarily sound really bad on the surface, but I remember feeling
  125. uncomfortable hugging him. And I never for a long time I don't think I really understood why that was. And now that
  126. I'm maybe a little bit more emotionally healthy and I can kind of look back on the time I realized that it was more
  127. than just like hugs. He would just he would hug for too long. He would always make comments to me and the other guys
  128. about like you know how strong we were and how he wanted to wrestle us. Maybe it was a sexual thing now that I'm
  129. saying this out loud. I don't really know. But it made me uncomfortable. Let's just say that. And I think I never
  130. I would remove myself from situations sometimes to try to get away from it. Didn't always escape. But I think
  131. looking back on it, I go, man, I wish I would have just had the power to say no.
  132. I don't do that. I don't hug adults. You know, I don't feel comfortable with this. You know, I don't feel comfortable
  133. going to this person's house. I don't feel comfortable being around their dad. Whatever might have been, right? But
  134. there was a lack of skills and language with the ability to set that boundary to
  135. say, "No, this is my personal space. You're invading my personal space." And I feel
  136. uncomfortable. And I think I would have probably benefited from some therapy as a kid.
  137. Like I said, my family was not the most emotionally healthy family. I think any of us would be pretty quick to tell you
  138. that. But as I look back and I go, man, those boundaries would have been nice to have.
  139. I also look back and I go, for the closeness that my family has now and the ability to to converse about things, my
  140. my dad and I in particular, my mom and I, they've been on this podcast. We've talked about this before. If you're
  141. interested in that, go check out those interviews with them. I think they're really good. But our ability to
  142. communicate now, the three of us, and talk about the things that were hard and painful that we disliked, we have that
  143. now. And I look at it and I go, man, could we have done this when I was 12? Uh, and so I say that not so much from a
  144. place of like longing to go back. It's but from a place of like for those of you who are
  145. where you are now and you feel that way. Go do it. Go get the help because man, the ability to
  146. have conversations with difficult people sometimes. And mom, dad, I'm not saying
  147. you're difficult, but the ability to to know the skills that you have, to have those
  148. conversations, to put words to the emotions that you feel is absolutely incredible and has been, I think, one of
  149. the biggest game changers in my life and is still growing. It's still I'm not perfect at it. We're getting there. So
  150. yeah, I think encouraging emotional health in school would have been a gamecher. I think those are the main
  151. three things. One, a better understanding of how our country works, the government played out by actual like
  152. experience going to those places, asking questions of elected officials, getting
  153. involved in, I don't know, town halls, protests, understanding how our voting system works. Number two, I think it
  154. would been really cool to have curriculum that expanded upon the religious beliefs of others and
  155. from a neutral point, not a jaded one-sidedness of Christianity is always right and these rest are already
  156. debunked beliefs. I think having that expansion of being able to look at them and put those shoes
  157. on, those hats on, whatever you want to call it, to look through the eyes of someone who believes something a little
  158. bit different would have been really cool. And also access to people to ask questions. You know, most people are
  159. very friendly. Most people want to share what they believe with you. And if you do it right, you can do it in a
  160. non-hostile type of way and still walk away being friends. And then the third thing, setting boundaries for myself.
  161. more than just saying no. But, you know, I look at my life even today and and recognize that like I struggle with the
  162. clients I work with sometimes telling them no and ending up working extra hours for things that I don't get paid
  163. enough to do, you know, and so looking at that and going, man, is this a skill that I could have learned back at a
  164. younger age? And so emotional health and learning how that plays a role in your education and being the healthiest
  165. version of yourself. And so yeah, those are really the main three things. I know
  166. it's hopefully it's not anything too shocking. Thank you for listening. Thank you
  167. for supporting. And uh yeah, I don't know. I got anything else? I don't think so. Uh tune in next week. We'll have
  168. another great episode. And if you stayed this long, maybe think about joining my
  169. newsletter. All right. Uh until next time. All right. Peace. [Music] [Music]

Brief Summary

Jacob Gooden reflects on his homeschooling, suggesting improvements in civic education, religious curriculum, and emotional health training.

Key points

  • Three Things I Would Change. Jacob shares three key aspects he wishes were different in his homeschooling experience: understanding government, exploring diverse religions, and learning to set boundaries.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes