3 Things I'd Change About My Homeschool Experience | #34
Ask about Ex-Homeschoolers Club
Episode Description
Join the Newsletter for the latest Ex-Homeschooler News: https://exhsclub.beehiiv.com/subscribe
In this episode of The Ex-Homeschoolers Club, I'm reflecting on a decade of being homeschooled and dive into three specific areas I would approach differently if I had the chance to go back. While I appreciate much of what my parents did, this episode explores critical reflections on my understanding of government, religious curriculum, and emotional boundaries. I also unpack how these elements have impacted my adult life and what I think future homeschoolers can do better. Whether you're a current homeschooler, a curious ex-homeschooler, or just someone interested in education reform, this one's for you.
*Key Takeaways:* - Government Education Matters: I discuss the missed opportunity to deeply understand local and state politics beyond textbooks—through field trips, town hall meetings, and active involvement. - Challenging Religious Narratives: Why I'd encourage exposure to a broader spectrum of belief systems rather than faith-based exclusivity in every subject. - Emotional Boundaries in Education: The crucial need for learning to set boundaries, communicate discomfort, and recognize the importance of emotional well-being from a young age. - The Power of Perspective: Looking back on my homeschool journey offers powerful lessons for educators, parents, and students alike. - Self-Reflection as Growth: Honest retrospection is key to personal development and helps create better systems for the next generation.
*Timestamps* 00:00 Welcome Back to the Ex-Homeschoolers Club 00:35 Reflecting on 10 Years of Homeschooling 01:00 Understanding Government and Politics 03:11 Challenging Religious Curriculum 12:21 The Importance of Emotional Boundaries 16:38 Conclusion and Final Thoughts
If you enjoyed this conversation, be sure to subscribe, leave a review, and share it with a friend who might benefit from hearing this story. Follow Ex-Homeschoolers Club on Instagram and TikTok for updates, and send us a message – we’d love to hear from you!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/exhsclub/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@exhsclub Email me at [email protected]
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- I was homeschooled for 10 years and while most of it I view very positively, there's three main things that I wish
- could have been done maybe a little bit differently. Hey, my name is Jacob Gooden and uh if you're new here, this
- is the Exhomeschoolers club, the best exhomeschooler podcast this side of the internet. Normally I've got guests on.
- We chat about the good, the bad, and the ugly of growing up a homeschool kid. So
- if that's you, you're in the right place. Okay. And for anyone who's returning, hey, how's it going? Welcome
- back. You heard me right. I'm going to talk about three things that I would do differently in my homeschool experience.
- I want to preface with this. I was homeschooled for 10 years from second grade all the way through high school. I
- think my parents did a decent job. I think it turned out okay. I'm not the dumbest guy in the room. Also, maybe not
- the smartest guy in the room, but I made it. I'm an adult. I'm surviving. We're okay. That being said, I think that
- there's three things that if I could go back in time and tell my my parents at a
- younger age be like, "Hey, I think maybe do these." These are them. So, number one, I think just a better understanding
- of how our country works. And I'm speaking from a United States of America perspective here, but how does our
- country work? I sometimes question that dayto-day. And you know, I have a decent
- understanding of history, right? I understand how this country came to be. I understand the founding documents. I
- understand. I've read all that stuff. I understand there's three branches of government. Like, I get it. I think what
- was missing was maybe not so much of the class aspect of like here's how government works. What I think was
- missing was seeing how it plays out and affects our day-to-day lives. So for me,
- I look at that and I go, I think the missed opportunity was an involvement in local and state
- politics. Now, that doesn't mean like I wanted to be governor of California or, you know, even serve in local
- government, but I think it would have been really cool to do field trips to state capital. I think it would have
- been really fun to meet elected officials, be able to ask them about their job and what they do and how they
- vote and how they listen to their constituents. Going to town hall meetings and like learning about what
- that looks like and how do we stand up and you know these are our elected officials. We put them in office to
- enact the will of the people and we are the people. So, how do we communicate that best to them? And I think it would
- have just been really cool to have a lot of those real hands-on experiences, right? And homeschooling is a hands-on
- experience. A lot of people cite that as being one of the main reasons they want
- to homeschool, right? Is that ability to give their kids like unique experiences.
- What better way than like teach them how the the world works. So I think that now
- as an adult and getting much more heavily involved in politics and an understanding of how this country works,
- I look at it and I go this would have been so easy to accomplish. It's timeconuming obviously but it would have
- been the the information is there so to speak. It's just a matter of actually like going and doing it. So that's
- number one. Number two is that I would push back on my parents a little bit of involving religion in
- every curriculum that we had. Now, I think religion is can be important and for a lot of homeschool families,
- religion is like a key proponent of why you homeschool your kids. For the person
- I am today, that's not a good enough reason to homeschool your kids is religion solely. But I do understand it,
- right? I understand wanting to have a little bit more control over the things that your child is learning. When you
- limit everything that you're being taught into a bubble, and religion to some degree is a bubble, you block out
- voices that could have compelling arguments. And so for me, I think being able to as as
- I've gotten older and being able to explore a more diverse look at the world and ask questions of other religions and
- other belief systems and and things like that, it's been very eye opening to kind
- of just like feel it out, right, and figure out what I believe on my own. So, let me
- give you kind of an example, right? because I can talk hypotheticals all day, but let me give you an example.
- Science for a lot of Christian homeschoolers is very Bible- based, right? And so you have this historical
- part and this faith-based part, right? And they work together to to reconcile it, right? So we believe in like young
- earth. We believe in, you know, literal 7-day creation as a Christian. I'm speaking as a Christian at this at this
- point. We believe in things like Noah's ark, right? and Noah's ark being a key catalyst in the laying down of a ton of
- fossils that we find today, right? And so I grew up believing all of this and yeah, there was maybe a little bit of an
- emphasis on like evolution, but it was always from a standpoint of yeah, but evolution has already been debunked. We
- know that that's not true, so kind of don't worry about it. Which creates in itself its own
- problems of like evolution is not debunked first and foremost. Um, some people would argue it
- is, but but I don't think it is. It's it's a commonly held belief by many people that that's what happened, right?
- And so rather than just kind of like pushing it off to the side and saying, "Oh, that's an already debunked theory.
- We don't really need to focus too much on it. Here's like an overview of of understanding it." I think that being
- able to look at Let's talk about creation. I think being able to look at an account of here's what we here's how
- we think the world started, right? from a from a biblical perspective of God spoke it into existence and it was a
- literal seven days and he built all of these things in in those days to looking at like an evolutionary perspective and
- understanding okay so the big bang like let's talk about that and let's look at the the intricacies of of what would
- need to happen to to do that right can we replicate that is that being replicated in other galaxies those types
- of questions and then you talk about the evolution of like where do trees come come from? Where does where does human
- come from? Where does human come from? Where do humans come from? Another really interesting one, and I learned
- more about this when I got to college because I took geology when I was in college. It was a rocky time, uh, if you
- will. Um, but I thought one of the most interesting parts about that class was we were discussing how rock layers were
- were laid down over time and how to assess the amount of time between rock layers. And
- so I grew up believing again the Bible and believing in Noah's arc and the worldwide flood, right? And also
- believing that that was a massive catalyst in the world that killed thousands, millions, I don't know, lots
- of living beings and they were, you know, buried underwater and under soil and and things like that, right? And so
- when we are looking at like the fossils and we're looking for fossils, we can find stuff from that time. And then I
- took this geology class and like I said it was it was interesting to talk about the length of time and understanding how
- if you've ever looked at a rock structure. Let's talk about the Grand Canyon. Like if you've ever been to the
- Grand Canyon, you look at the Grand Canyon, it's like all these lines up the Grand Canyon. And it's really
- fascinating how it's time, right? It's a symbol of time that's going up. And so to look at the opposition of
- Christianity, which you know is that these layers get laid down over thousands, hundreds, thousands, millions
- of years, things get trapped inside of them. And what that means, right? And how do things get trapped inside of
- them? Sometimes it's quickly by rushing water. Sometimes it's slow by dying out in the wilderness and rotting away. And
- then, you know, over time just dust blows and, you know, maybe some waters come through and whatever else. But that
- diversity of like thinking I thought was really interesting. And again, I went to
- a Christian college, so a lot of this still steeped in religion when it comes to the
- sciences, but starting to ask those questions of like, well, what if, you know, and some people would argue those
- are really dangerous. Is it really dangerous to ask questions? I don't think so. I think it's I personally
- think it's really fun because it pushes you to find answers, right? And the strongest argument I always hear for
- faith is that well at some point you just got to believe, right? You just got to take a
- leap of faith, so to speak. And this episode is not meant to be, you know, sway you on
- religion or anything like that, but I just I always find it interesting because uh in conversations I have with
- friends who are still believers and still believe in like literal 7-day creationism and young earth theory and
- things like that. It's always interesting because they get we get to a point in the conversation where
- sometimes they just go, "Well, okay, but at some point you just got to like have
- faith that this is what it is." And ultimately, yeah, I understand. like I also have to have faith that in whatever
- I believe of like how did the world really start? So anyway, the reason I bring this up as a point that I would
- change in my curriculum is not so much of being like, oh well now I'm not a Christian and I wish that my parents had
- given me the knowledge beforehand. No, I I bring it up because initially when I was presented with these
- ideas, they became really good talking points for me to like discuss and ask questions about. And I think that that
- was so much lacking in my my curriculum growing up of everything was faith-based
- from science to English to math to just everything was just had this layer of Christianity in it. Once I stepped
- outside of that and I started to be able to ask questions about other religions.
- I loved Greek mythology growing up. But it was just that. It was mythology. It was a storytelling mechanism, right? And
- it was an explanation as to why the world was the way it was. Why did it thunder? Oh, well, it must have been
- Zeus, right? And what happens when you die? Well, you go to the underworld and there's u Hades, right? And I loved
- Greek mythology because I looked at it as this kind of an explainer of the world before we
- had modern day science. As humans, we put these characters, so to speak, and on these pedestals to look at. But I was
- never I never really understood why we didn't actually look at it from the perspective of there were
- people who fully believed this who were dedicated to this type of religion. Why was that? What led them to
- that? And so I think just the diversity aspect of it would have been really cool
- to understand argue modern day religion. Why do Buddhists believe what they believe? Why do Mormons believe what
- they believe? How is it really all that different? And less so from a combative spo space. Um because I think maybe
- that's more what I have the the issue with is the combative place of religion in our
- curriculums where it was always Christianity is right 100% of the time. All other religions are fake. And so you
- go into it with a jaded knowledge that all other religions are already fake. So, I don't really h they hold no
- authority over me. And I I don't know. I just think it's an interesting thing if
- you can teach somebody to maybe put that opposite thinking on temporarily to be like, "Okay, what would it take for me
- to actually believe this other thing?" Maybe that's more what I'm getting at. So, you could disagree with me. That's
- fine. I'm totally down for that. And this again is some dude on the internet just sharing his thoughts of what he
- would change about his homeschool experience. The la the last point I wanted to talk about was less from an
- education perspective in the traditional sense of like a curriculum and more from
- like an emotions and psychological perspective and that was I think that my parents could have done a better job of
- teaching me boundaries. My homeschooling experience was I'm not going to say unique. I think
- everybody's is unique. There was four of us that lived in that house and two of us were homeschooled and two of us were
- the adults. None of us I think were super emotionally healthy people. And so I don't hold anything against my
- parents. I think they did the best they could with what they were given. And what's cool is now as we've gotten older
- and we've become much more emotionally healthy, I think we are just in better places with each other to some degree or
- we understand ourselves better, maybe know how to communicate it better. So I want to kind of preface with that. But
- boundaries for me is something that is one of my big focuses for 2025. And as I've been working on it and
- learning the power of no and and things like that, I keep getting reminded of experiences from when I was a kid. And
- when I was in high school and junior high, one of my friends dads was just like a very hugging person. He was very
- like he just liked hugs. And that doesn't necessarily sound really bad on the surface, but I remember feeling
- uncomfortable hugging him. And I never for a long time I don't think I really understood why that was. And now that
- I'm maybe a little bit more emotionally healthy and I can kind of look back on the time I realized that it was more
- than just like hugs. He would just he would hug for too long. He would always make comments to me and the other guys
- about like you know how strong we were and how he wanted to wrestle us. Maybe it was a sexual thing now that I'm
- saying this out loud. I don't really know. But it made me uncomfortable. Let's just say that. And I think I never
- I would remove myself from situations sometimes to try to get away from it. Didn't always escape. But I think
- looking back on it, I go, man, I wish I would have just had the power to say no.
- I don't do that. I don't hug adults. You know, I don't feel comfortable with this. You know, I don't feel comfortable
- going to this person's house. I don't feel comfortable being around their dad. Whatever might have been, right? But
- there was a lack of skills and language with the ability to set that boundary to
- say, "No, this is my personal space. You're invading my personal space." And I feel
- uncomfortable. And I think I would have probably benefited from some therapy as a kid.
- Like I said, my family was not the most emotionally healthy family. I think any of us would be pretty quick to tell you
- that. But as I look back and I go, man, those boundaries would have been nice to have.
- I also look back and I go, for the closeness that my family has now and the ability to to converse about things, my
- my dad and I in particular, my mom and I, they've been on this podcast. We've talked about this before. If you're
- interested in that, go check out those interviews with them. I think they're really good. But our ability to
- communicate now, the three of us, and talk about the things that were hard and painful that we disliked, we have that
- now. And I look at it and I go, man, could we have done this when I was 12? Uh, and so I say that not so much from a
- place of like longing to go back. It's but from a place of like for those of you who are
- where you are now and you feel that way. Go do it. Go get the help because man, the ability to
- have conversations with difficult people sometimes. And mom, dad, I'm not saying
- you're difficult, but the ability to to know the skills that you have, to have those
- conversations, to put words to the emotions that you feel is absolutely incredible and has been, I think, one of
- the biggest game changers in my life and is still growing. It's still I'm not perfect at it. We're getting there. So
- yeah, I think encouraging emotional health in school would have been a gamecher. I think those are the main
- three things. One, a better understanding of how our country works, the government played out by actual like
- experience going to those places, asking questions of elected officials, getting
- involved in, I don't know, town halls, protests, understanding how our voting system works. Number two, I think it
- would been really cool to have curriculum that expanded upon the religious beliefs of others and
- from a neutral point, not a jaded one-sidedness of Christianity is always right and these rest are already
- debunked beliefs. I think having that expansion of being able to look at them and put those shoes
- on, those hats on, whatever you want to call it, to look through the eyes of someone who believes something a little
- bit different would have been really cool. And also access to people to ask questions. You know, most people are
- very friendly. Most people want to share what they believe with you. And if you do it right, you can do it in a
- non-hostile type of way and still walk away being friends. And then the third thing, setting boundaries for myself.
- more than just saying no. But, you know, I look at my life even today and and recognize that like I struggle with the
- clients I work with sometimes telling them no and ending up working extra hours for things that I don't get paid
- enough to do, you know, and so looking at that and going, man, is this a skill that I could have learned back at a
- younger age? And so emotional health and learning how that plays a role in your education and being the healthiest
- version of yourself. And so yeah, those are really the main three things. I know
- it's hopefully it's not anything too shocking. Thank you for listening. Thank you
- for supporting. And uh yeah, I don't know. I got anything else? I don't think so. Uh tune in next week. We'll have
- another great episode. And if you stayed this long, maybe think about joining my
- newsletter. All right. Uh until next time. All right. Peace. [Music] [Music]
Brief Summary
Jacob Gooden reflects on his homeschooling, suggesting improvements in civic education, religious curriculum, and emotional health training.
Key points
- Three Things I Would Change. Jacob shares three key aspects he wishes were different in his homeschooling experience: understanding government, exploring diverse religions, and learning to set boundaries.





