Why Homeschooling Needs Accountability...and What We Can Do About It

Ex-Homeschoolers Club

Ask about Ex-Homeschoolers Club

Episode Description

In this episode of The Ex-Homeschoolers Club, I'm sitting down with Tess Ulrey, Executive Director of the ⁠Coalition for Responsible Home Education (CRHE)⁠. Tess shares her experience growing up homeschooled across multiple countries, transitioning in and out of public, private, and international schools, and how those experiences shaped her work advocating for homeschool children today.

Together, they unpack the privilege embedded in homeschooling, the blurry lines between homeschooling and unschooling, the challenges many homeschool alumni face in college and adulthood, and why responsible oversight matters—not to punish families, but to protect kids.

This conversation explores the good, the bad, and the uncomfortable realities of homeschooling, including abuse, neglect, and the gaps that exist in state laws across the U.S.

*Key Topics Covered* - Tess’s experience being homeschooled in Michigan, Japan, and Germany - Homeschooling vs. unschooling—and why the line is blurrier than ever - The role of privilege in homeschooling decisions - Transitioning from homeschooling to college and adult life - Why many homeschool alumni hide their education background - How public schools and community organizations fill critical support gaps - The mission and work of the Coalition for Responsible Home Education - The reality of abuse, neglect, and lack of oversight in homeschooling laws - Current legislation impacting homeschool children in the U.S.

*Resources & Links* - Coalition for Responsible Home Education: ⁠https://crhe.org⁠ - Homeschooling's Invisible Children Database: ⁠https://hic.crhe.org⁠

*Connect with Me* - Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/exhsclub/ - TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@exhsclub - Email me at [email protected] - Newsletter: https://exhsclub.beehiiv.com/

If you’re a former homeschooler, your story matters. Consider connecting with CRHE to support research, advocacy, and responsible policy that centers the lived experiences of homeschool alumni.

*Chapters* 00:00 Coming Up 00:44 Meet Tess Ulrey 01:43 Tess's Homeschooling Journey 04:12 Transitioning Between Education Systems 08:14 Defining Homeschooling and Unschooling 10:17 Challenges and Benefits of Unschooling 14:09 College and Career: Post-Homeschooling Life 18:18 Nonprofit Work and Community Support 23:03 Public Schooling Decision for Tess's Kids 26:41 The Coalition for Responsible Home Education 33:05 How to Get Involved with CRHE 44:42 Conclusion and Call to Action

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. A lot of times in homeschooling conversations, I don't think we talk enough about the privilege that
  2. homeschooling [music] truly is. I believe definitionally that someone can be a homeschooler and an unschooler at
  3. the same [music] time. I think homeschooling is a great choice for some people, but it is again rooted in a in a
  4. privilege [music] that not everybody has. Anecdotally, we know that homeschoolers tend to, you know, maybe
  5. have some pretty good outcomes, [music] but homeschoolers also have really bad outcomes. Homeschooling is not is not
  6. free of abuse and neglect. In 48 states, someone can be convicted of a violent crime against children and still be
  7. allowed to homeschool their own child. That's an incredible safety risk, especially when the perpetrator is
  8. likely someone at home. [music] Welcome back to the Ex Homeschoolers Club. I am your host, Jacob Gooden.
  9. This, if you're [music] new here, this is the place where we talk about the good, the bad, and the ugly of growing
  10. up a homeschool kid. Today, I'm so blessed to have Tess uh on with me. She is a new exhomie friend and uh we're
  11. going to talk not only about her experience uh as a homeschool kid, but also about her involvement in a great
  12. organization called the Coalition for Responsible Home Educators. And uh yeah, but more about that in a little bit. So,
  13. first and foremost, Tess, welcome to the Ex Homeschoolers Club. This is me granting you your your membership card.
  14. >> Thank you so much. I appreciate it. Um, I'm really uh really excited to to to
  15. talk about to talk about an experience that was pivotal for me. Um, I was homeschooled for six out of my 12 years
  16. of of education. Uh, and now working um at CR, the Coalition for Responsible Home Education, I'm able to really
  17. center that experience and I'm excited about uh our conversation today and then what homeschooling looks like in the
  18. future, too. >> Very cool. Yeah. Well, let's let's get started with your experience and kind of
  19. lay it out for me. I mean, you said it right there. So, six out of 12 years as a as a homeschooler. Um, I did a little
  20. bit more than that. Um, but uh I'm trying to I think mine was 10 a 10 out of the 12 years or something like that.
  21. So, uh so you know I got to be a little bit but you know still you still got a big flavor for it. So So tell me about
  22. your home school experience like was it all the way were the six years all together? Were they separated out a
  23. little bit? And uh and just walk me through maybe like a day in the life. >> Yeah, absolutely. So, I feel like it's
  24. always important to homeschool conversations to to tell you uh you know where I was in in the United States and
  25. also where where I am in the family. So, um I was homeschooled I was homeschooled
  26. um mostly in Michigan. Um and I am the oldest of five of five children. That's not unusual um as I as I have more and
  27. more um homeschool conversations uh to kind of you know navigate that big family that that big family atmosphere.
  28. But like I mentioned, I was homeschooled in Michigan. Um, homeschooling. I'm gonna date myself a little bit. I
  29. was born in 1988, and homeschooling actually became legal here in Michigan in 1996. So, I was um I was pulled out
  30. of school um right around third grade um because my parents were really really dissatisfied with the kind of
  31. the condition of of the public school system. Uh my my mom talks about how, you know, I was coming home at first I
  32. was excited to learn and then I was coming home bored. I couldn't tell her what I was doing in class. And you know,
  33. as a parent and actually with an education background herself, that was I think really really difficult for her to
  34. see because um as a parent myself now, that's terrible when you see that your kids um you know are disinterested and
  35. bored and you want to fix that. So my um so at that point I was pulled out of school. Um my younger my younger
  36. siblings um some of them stayed in school for a little bit longer, but ultimately that was kind of the
  37. beginning of my family's um homeschool journey. it was right on the edge of being legal of of being legal in
  38. Michigan. So even though you know seven, eight-year-old tests didn't have that much of a recollection of of that. Um
  39. it's been an interesting conversation with my parents as adults to figure out the the loopholes they they kind of went
  40. through and the hurdles they had to they had to um overcome because homeschooling
  41. was that important to them. And what I will say is that I was homeschooled I was homeschooled in Michigan. Um but um
  42. I'm an auto industry kid. Michigan. Makes sense, right? Um, and so my family actually moved moved around quite a bit.
  43. Uh, we moved we moved to Japan and then back to the United States and then to Germany and back to the United States.
  44. In those other countries, um, Germany is a great example of a place where homeschooling is actually completely
  45. illegal. So, me coming in and out of the school system is also reflective of my place of where I was. Um, as I moved
  46. between those school systems, sometimes it was, you know, I started in a public school. Um, I went to private school, I
  47. went to an international school, and then after coming back to the United States, I actually wound up graduating
  48. high school. Um, I think I was one of the first virtual kind of one of the first virtual high school graduates as
  49. well. So, that's a bit of background about my my homeschooling experience. Like I said, it moved in and out of
  50. different um it moved in and out of different systems. And I think that now in my professional career, it's really
  51. important that I have that um that kind of balance of those of those different education modalities.
  52. >> That's so interesting about like I I knew that in other countries homeschooling is kind of like yeah,
  53. borderline illegal or very difficult to get into sometimes. And so um but yeah, I knew in Germany that it it's illegal.
  54. So I I'm I'm uh I'm a little curious like I mean you had already had some public school experience, but like the
  55. transition to move to Germany. I mean one as a kid is probably big shift but is it then also a huge shift in the
  56. education experience to be like okay now I'm in I'm in German school. >> Yeah. So it was um I attended
  57. international schools which I mean no language barrier those those are in English but it is a great opportunity to
  58. connect with children who have wildly different experiences. You know education modality is not the only it's
  59. kind of not the only not the only difference there. going in and out of different school systems was always it
  60. was always challenging because it's learning it's learning a new set of norms. It's learning a new you know a
  61. lot of times essentially a new language um you know language of education I mean
  62. learning learning new social connections and and everything everything that comes
  63. along with that. So, um, moving in and out was definitely was definitely an experience, but I think again it was,
  64. um, ultimately valuable because I think it gave me a different understanding of homeschooling as well because I was
  65. moving in and out of more traditional education systems. Um, I was a little bit more familiar, I think, than some of
  66. my peers with the idea of things like standardized testing, um, grading, you know, all of those things. I know a lot
  67. of my peers who went, you know, all the way all the way up through homeschooling, some of those were really
  68. really foreign concepts. I felt like I at least had a had a baseline understanding. I was going to ask you
  69. too cuz you mentioned so your mom had a little bit of an education background. My mom a little bit similar. She wanted
  70. to be high school teacher. And so when it came time for when she started homeschooling uh my sister and I I was
  71. second grade, second or third grade, and my sister was in kindergarten. But the first couple years she really structured
  72. it like a more of a traditional school. And so um which didn't really didn't really work. We found out pretty
  73. quickly. But I'm wondering in your experience with with your mom like did she kind of do that or how how did her
  74. how did her homeschooling change throughout that time too? Also, I mean there there's gaps in there where you're
  75. going to traditional school and things like that, but how how did that shift? I know at the at the beginning of our
  76. homeschool journey, it was it was definitely more structured and I think that, you know, relied on some of those
  77. school room mechanisms um and and performance indicators as I grew up and again with four with four sisters behind
  78. me um I could see how it's a little bit different for everyone. I think that my parents really started to embrace more
  79. of the um more of the unschooling kind of theory. um you know, I think the more confident
  80. they got in homeschooling and um just the more experiences that my family gained, I know that my youngest sister's
  81. um my youngest sister's homeschool experience probably followed unschooling a little bit more than homeschooling. Um
  82. if I were to really examine how those, you know, how those looked just eight years apart.
  83. >> And for you, I'm curious because I know people people define homeschool and unschool in like all these different
  84. ways. So like for you, >> how do you define those terms? For me, homeschooling is just any
  85. parent-directed education that happens mostly at home. Um, I believe definitionally that someone can be a
  86. homeschooler and an unschooler at the same at the same time. Um so for me unschooling means that you abandon some
  87. of those constraints around um I guess assessed grade level um performance indicators some of those academic
  88. benchmarks that are used with the idea that you know a child can direct that themselves rather than the parent
  89. directed component of it. Um, those are really interesting things to look at because I think especially now with
  90. virtual schooling becoming so much so much more common since the pandemic. Sometimes people's interpretation of
  91. homeschooling is very much just rigid classroom behavior but sitting, you know, kind of like you and I are sitting
  92. here right now, right? We're just >> we're screen to screen instead of instead of face to face in a classroom.
  93. Um, and unschooling takes a little bit more of that creative license. Um, so I think that there's yeah there's
  94. definitely there's definitely a middle ground in there too. No, I I I'm probably with you in kind of that like I
  95. think unschooling is like a form of of homeschool or at least my view like traditional homeschool, but yeah, with
  96. the rise like with the pandemic and now everything a lot of things becoming virtual and I know a lot of kids now
  97. that do like the road schooling thing where their family lives in an RV and like but they they technically go to
  98. public school and I'm like but they're kind of homeschooled and it's it's like this weird like I'm like the lines are
  99. blurry I guess is what I'm trying to say where growing up I had is very definitive of like homeschool is mom and
  100. dad are choosing my curriculum and they're building it themselves. Um you know and they're they're piecing
  101. together what was working for us and so there's this individualistic aspect to it where it's like hey if my
  102. kid is really into this like we're going to lean heavily into that. Um there's some customization in the homeschool
  103. world that I think uh lacks in the public school. That's that's my opinion. But um
  104. >> definitely and I think that like turn that my parents took kind of towards unschooling um you know I definitely
  105. found it um you know in my in my in my later teen years as well um that's kind of self-directed education and what I
  106. was interested in um definitely was kind of a hallmark of you know my I feel like
  107. my teen my my teen experience in homeschooling because I had um some of the autonomy to do that right and to
  108. figure out what I was interested in and what mattered to me. uh the the challenge I think comes in that you know
  109. a lot of times in high school it's also when you are learning to um adhere to some of those other some of those other
  110. norms as well and so for things like you know things like math and things like science I'm going to be honest I was not
  111. interested um and so those things became very difficult for me especially especially without the you know
  112. boundaries of a classroom around that uh so that's that's the part I think of unschooling that sometimes becomes a
  113. little bit tricky for families right because you want you want children to be able to explor what they're interested
  114. in and you want them to be able to have that autonomy. Um, but at the same time,
  115. you have to learn math and I did, but it was a struggle. >> Yeah, I I feel you. There was definitely
  116. I think like you, my my high school experience was like a little bit of that like there was some structure, there was
  117. some understanding of like what my my parents had a very um >> they wanted my sister and I to be able
  118. to go to college. That was the the end the end goal was not just get them through high school. The end goal was
  119. get them through high school and launched into whatever is next. So college, job, um marriage, whatever that
  120. next step is, adulthood. Um and I think that that kind of differentiated them from other homesooled parents who were
  121. just like, we're getting through high school and then that's it and you're on your own and you'll figure out life.
  122. >> Yeah. And so because they had that structure to them, there was kind of there was an understanding of like,
  123. okay, you're gonna need XYZ science and that was explained to me. Okay, so that's important. I think I want to go
  124. to college. I'm going to need chemistry. I'm going to need biology. I'm going to
  125. need all these different things. I'm going to need all these different levels of math. Um, and so it did help. I think
  126. it helped me actually because it gave me that motivation of like if I want to launch successfully, I'm going to need
  127. this. um you know, and even if it's just kind of a like learn it to regurgitate it type of situation, I need to be able
  128. to do that uh to get to the next level of life. >> Um maybe not the healthiest way to look
  129. at it, but it was definitely that was my experience with it. And so >> I I'm wondering for for you like did
  130. your parents have a similar desire to not only see their kids graduate, but then like launch su I'm going to say
  131. successfully, but launch into the real world? >> Definitely. I think um a lot of
  132. commonalities in that story as well. I remember, you know, as a teenager fighting with my mother about doing math
  133. because that's what we do. And that was a part of it, you know, is that Tess, you need to go to college. Tess, you
  134. need to, you know, kind of take that, you know, you you need to kind of take that next step. So, um both my parents
  135. have four-year um you know, have four-year degrees. They actually have master's degrees. Um I undercut them
  136. there a little bit. So, both my parents have have professional degrees. Um and so, it was always kind of assumed that
  137. college was college was the next step for us. And that was definitely for my sisters and I um held as sort of the
  138. the common step that happened after high school. Um I think that in the entire in
  139. the entire education landscape right now, the conversations we're having with students are a lot different about what
  140. you do after after high school. I think that there's a lot more conversation about things like, you know, things like
  141. trade schools and training or these secondary options that are not just four-year universities. Um but for me
  142. back in the early 2000s, dating myself again there, um that was really what you what was you know assumed was that was
  143. that you went to college right after high school. And so my parents um I think did try to set me up as best they
  144. possibly could for college. Um ultimately I did I did go to college right after um right after I turned 18
  145. um entered my freshman year. I failed out miserably. Um, I think that for me, um, being able to direct my own
  146. education so much, um, in high school and not having a ton of experience in kind of what you said, like the
  147. regurgitating part of it, um, was really really hard for me. I struggled to function in a classroom environment. Um,
  148. because I wasn't I just wasn't used to it. I, you know, on on a very frank level, I also wasn't used to having to
  149. do things that I wasn't interested in and didn't want to do. And sometimes that's the reality of classes in
  150. college, right? Is that you just have to do it. Um, and ultimately I think I struggled socially as well because
  151. coming from um, a, you know, coming from a homeschool experience and while I was
  152. connected in terms of a lot of the artistic pursuits that I was interested in at the time, um, it's still a lot
  153. different to function in that type of peer environment. So, um, I I did go to college. My parents set me up for, like
  154. I said, as best they possibly could. Um, but it was not it was not the fit for me
  155. in any in any way, shape, or form uh at at that time in my life. I don't necessarily blame homeschooling for that
  156. experience. I think it was I think there were a lot of factors in there. Um, but
  157. it is an interesting thing to consider about had I had a more traditional education experience or even a high
  158. school experience how that h how that might have been um how that might have been different.
  159. >> Yeah. But what I will say is that once I once I failed out miserably, um, you
  160. know, I I do credit homeschooling with getting me um kind of getting my feet under me and figuring out what the what
  161. it was I wanted to do next. Um, I I was always very empowered to pursue opportunities that I was interested in
  162. and to kind of work creatively outside the bounds of a traditional a traditional education or in this case a
  163. traditional professional career. So, I actually um I started my nonprofit journey because I was I was teaching art
  164. classes at a local YMCA and then just really um kind of fell in love with nonprofit work, the way that we fill
  165. this critical gap between what societyy's able to offer and what policy um can't meet. And really, I I launched
  166. my professional career um at a YMCA. Uh, so I'm happy to, you know, be on the kind of be on the other side of that, be
  167. on the other side of that now. Um, I'm 37 years old. I'm the executive director of the Coalition for Responsible Home
  168. Education. Um, and I'm actually back in school now. So, uh, maybe I I I will get
  169. that college thing done eventually. >> That That's so interesting. Like, you said a lot of things there that I'm
  170. like, okay, I gota I want to touch on all these different things. But yeah, >> so one, I mean, I remember too, like my
  171. my freshman year of college, similar to you, I I didn't um I I don't think I struggled nearly as much. Um, and part
  172. of that I I had some in-classroom experiences in in my later high school years where I was going to a classroom
  173. or I was taking some kind of class. And so I had a little bit of structure and I
  174. think of of like understanding what that looked like. Like and so when I got to college, I was like I I struggled with
  175. the like similar to you of like I'm not interested in this, so like why would I even bother waste my time with it? And
  176. then other things I was just like way smarter than the the class like and I I don't say that to be like, you know, to
  177. to be boastful, but like I took an intro to business class and I was like I had already run multiple businesses in high
  178. school and I was like I I know all this stuff. I could have tested out of this very easily. Um and the professor hated
  179. me because I just was like well that actually doesn't work. like I pushed back on like every idea he had kind of a
  180. thing. Um to the point where he was just like shut up and listen. And I'm sure there were things that I I did not know,
  181. you know, being 18 and thinking you you know everything in the world. But um but
  182. it was definitely like it was frustrating because I had been used to >> that much more unstructured environment
  183. where it was like it was okay to push back on ideas and it was okay to just like go do things and test and
  184. experiment and um >> there wasn't formulas for like this is going to work and this isn't going to
  185. work. Like it was just all about like going and doing that. Um I'm interested. Yeah. You talked about working in the
  186. YMCA. Is that something that had started previous to college where you had been involved in like community type things
  187. like that or or how did you how did you find that and how did you you know get involved in the nonprofit stuff? Um I'm
  188. always interested you know where where those passions kind of spring from? >> I was always involved artistically I in
  189. you know dance, visual art, theater, whatever sort of artistic mechanism I could get my hands on um as a child and
  190. you know into into young adulthood. I was very very involved that way. Um there wasn't necessarily an intersection
  191. with you know with nonprofit work but I was like a lot of us I was raised in the
  192. church and so that idea of service to others was something that was deeply deeply ingrained in me from a young from
  193. a young age. I'm part of the ELCA Lutheran church. Um that's the church I grew up in. And so that again the idea
  194. of service to others um was was deeply familiar to me. uh working working at the YMCA was my first uh was my first
  195. nonprofit experience. Um and it was interesting because it was a combination of that you know service to others that
  196. I had been that I had been raised with but with a larger community lens to it as well. And I think it was important
  197. for me to see these large structures of support that exist within within American society that help so
  198. many people. I wasn't in traditional school in the United States. And so I don't think I realized all of these
  199. other again just structures of support that kind of exist both for both for kids and for families. And so for me
  200. working at the YMCA for a long time um and then I worked for an organization called Girls on the Run and then I
  201. worked for the Boys and Girls Club as well. So my entire professional career um really has been dedicated to that to
  202. to that idea of these systems of support that happen in communities that are outside of the traditional school
  203. system. Um you know I think as homeschoolers sometimes there's a there's a large uh there's somewhat of a
  204. fear of the public school system but sometimes there can also be a a distrust of these other organizations that are
  205. kind of at that at at that same juncture. I'm a firm believer that education doesn't just happen in inside
  206. classroom walls. And especially seeing how so many so many people so so many of my peers accessed all of these resources
  207. through organizations um like the Boys and Girls Club and like the YMCA was important for my larger understanding of
  208. it. You know, it's it's so interesting like you you mentioned like you know like some of some of the failing not I'm
  209. going to say failings of schools but like those things that are missing those pieces that are missing that are getting
  210. met with things like the YMCA in and society boys and girls club. I worked at a library while I was in high school and
  211. it was right next to the Boys and Girls Club and they would come and they would you know do things with us at the
  212. library and we would go support them in the ways we could with story time or whatever. And um and I remember that was
  213. like a big shifting point similar to you where I was like I saw also you working
  214. at the library I don't think people realize how much services the library offers of like when it comes
  215. internet access. Yeah. Like it's insane. Um the library of things like just the the sheer amount of things that your
  216. library provides for you is is insane. Um and so so it kind of clicked in my brain I think when I was like 16 17
  217. years old of like oh the there there are these things that exist that are like filling these gaps um in the world. It
  218. clicked in my brain the importance of those things that I think gets lost a lot of times for people where they just
  219. see big numbers going and sometimes they're not big numbers but big amounts of money going into these things that
  220. they're like I'm not seeing any return on this investment so to speak, right? And it's like
  221. you you're not it's it's different. It's like a I'm I'm trying to think of the way how I how I I I know
  222. I've phrased this much better in the past and I'm jumbling my words here, but like there is a net positive to the
  223. education and the support that these programs bring uh to the world and so um anyway, so I commend you for for that
  224. work um for sure because it's it's it t it takes tough people to to do those jobs.
  225. >> Yeah. Yeah. I really um and that's really what brought me um to my current role at the Coalition for Responsible
  226. Home Education. We are a we are a 501c3 organization. Um and our mission is to empower homesooled children um in a in a
  227. lot of different capacities. And so I'm happy that I'm able to bring that kind of all of that nonprofit experience but
  228. really elevate again one of my one of my pivotal life experiences as well. So it's been interesting to kind of connect
  229. those connect those dots as an adult. Well, let's yeah, let's kind of get into, you know, and actually before we
  230. get into coalition more, I want to talk to you really quickly about because I know you're a mother with some kiddos
  231. and your kids are in public school. What went into the decision to put your kids
  232. in public school and how has that been? Did you think about homeschooling them? >> Yeah, definitely. And I I appreciate the
  233. question because especially I spend, you know, as you know, Jake, I spent all my
  234. time talking about homeschooling now. Um, but it's but it's not something that I, you know,
  235. >> I do as an adult. Um, I think that there's a couple I think there's a couple pieces of it that are that are
  236. important to consider just frankly in the larger homeschooling conversation as well. Um, I guess at the base level,
  237. homeschooling was never really an option for me. Um, I became a single parent when my daughters were very young. And a
  238. lot of times in homeschooling conversations, I don't think we talk enough about the privilege that
  239. homeschooling truly is. um you know for someone to do homeschooling well and to do homeschooling responsibly
  240. and to really deliver to children what it is they need um that requires I think sometimes the the capacity and the
  241. energy that as a single parent I was never going to be able to deliver. Um so for me it's it was not even really a
  242. there wasn't really a decision around it. It was never it was never an option if that is if if that makes sense. But
  243. from the time my daughters were young, I was I I did navigate something that was
  244. kind of brand new to me um as because because it wasn't something that I had experienced as a as a child. So I you
  245. know even before public school um I had my daughters in in daycare. Um I actually I was a single parent at the
  246. time and I actually accessed I actually accessed resources through Michigan to help me pay for daycare. And growing up
  247. in an environment where even though I was in public school, there was still kind of a cultivated fear of of of
  248. public school and sometimes of these larger systems of support that society um that society needs. It was it was
  249. hard for me to kind of take that jump and to move in that direction a little bit. Um, but ultimately I'm so glad I
  250. did because it I have seen my daughters just absolutely blossom, you know, academically, socially, um, and just as
  251. great sort of citizens of of of, you know, my of their school, of my town of Michigan. Um, and I credit the public
  252. school system a lot for that. Uh, I don't think I think homeschooling is a great choice for some people, but it is
  253. again rooted in a in a privilege that not everybody has. And so when we're having these conversations about about
  254. homeschooling, I I do think that's important to to to recognize as well that it is genuinely um it is genuinely
  255. a privileged piece as well. >> No, I I 100% agree with you. I I I have had a couple talks recently with my
  256. parents about the fact that like I I grew up in Southern California. It is not cheap to live in live in Southern
  257. California. I you know and so to live on one income and have my mom be a full-time stay-at-home mom with two kids
  258. and homeschool them and invest her time and energy into that. And then later my dad got more involved in our our
  259. education as well. And so like I don't take that lightly anymore and I recognize a little bit of that like
  260. sacrifice that happened there. Um, and so yeah, it's definitely like I think if the situation was different, like I I I
  261. wouldn't be sitting here talking about homeschooling because I would have been in public school. Um, and so no, I think
  262. that's a that's a very crucial piece to kind of touch on there is the fact that it is a very privileged place to come
  263. from when when you are a homeschool kid. Okay, so let's pivot a little bit into CRE,
  264. the Coalition for Responsible Home Education. you kind of have answered this already,
  265. but what really is it? Um, and like what what is the purpose? How do we get involved? How did you get involved with
  266. it and find it? And um, yeah, let's start there. >> Yeah. So, I um, the Coalition for
  267. Responsible Home Education, um, it's a nonprofit that was founded all the way back in 2013. Um it was the coalition
  268. for responsible home education was founded by alumni and remains um powered by alumni to to this day as well. Uh we
  269. work in kind of three three areas that are all centered around empowering empowering homesooled children. So we um
  270. a lot of the resources we create help alumni um with that transition between homeschooling and the real world. um in
  271. so many adult alumni that I that I talk to, we all kind of talk about this like reckoning that we had when we had to go
  272. into the real world. And so we do a lot of we do a lot of resource um you know resource building around that around
  273. around that transition time and um and build some resources for families that are currently homeschooling now. Um our
  274. focus remains alumni and will always remain alumni. Um but the reality is is that as more and more families are
  275. homeschooling, more and more families want to want to hear from us as well about how they can improve their current
  276. um homeschooling practice. So that's the resources thing that we do. Um we also do we we do some really really
  277. interesting research. Uh Dr. Jonah Stewart leads our research efforts. Um and that takes a lot of different I
  278. guess a lot of different methods, ways and things that we're trying to learn about. Uh one of our signature efforts
  279. there is maintaining the homeschoolings of the invisible children database. This
  280. is a uh this is a database of kind of extreme cases of abuse and neglect where homeschooling is is is a common thread
  281. throughout them. Um homeschooling is not is not free of abuse and neglect. Um a lot of times in homeschooling
  282. conversations we we tend to grant parents the all of the good intentions, right? there's a
  283. there's a presumption that if someone is homeschooling, they are a great person.
  284. Um, and that is true for the majority, right? But the reality is is that there is a subset of abuse and neglect that is
  285. happening. And that's what the HIC database maintains. Jonah also leads our research uh specifically into
  286. homeschooling outcomes as well because we want to have more real data around what it is homeschoolers do next. Um,
  287. working on this side of it, it's challenging because a lot of states states treat homeschooling differently
  288. in every way, shape, and form. So, we don't have a great idea sometimes of how many homeschoolers exist and we have an
  289. even worse idea of what happens next. Uh, I think anecdotally we know that homeschoolers tend to, you know, maybe
  290. have some pretty good outcomes, but homeschoolers also have really bad outcomes. Um, and we see both of those
  291. in our alumni and it's important for us to be able to present that from a data from a data standpoint. The final thing
  292. we do is actually um is actually around advocacy and specifically encouraging responsible oversight on a
  293. state-by-state basis to make sure that the children are accessing education, that children have a safe home
  294. environment um and that those negative outcomes that we see in research, there's a safety net around them that's
  295. created um from policy. So that's what that's what uh the Coalition for Responsible Home Education does. I um I
  296. came to the organization because they were in um an exciting place of growth and were able to hire an executive
  297. director for the very first time. So I when I applied to this uh when I applied to this job, it was the first time I had
  298. ever even mentioned I was homeschooled in a job interview, [laughter] cover letter, anything, you know, anything
  299. like that. Um and not only did I mention it, it was a selling point, which was crazy to me. Um because, you know, I'm
  300. deeply aware of the stigma that exists around homeschoolers. Um, and a lot of those stereotypes that kind of if I were
  301. to tell somebody I was homeschooled would come ahead of my professional experience. So, it's not something I
  302. shared. Um, people would find it out about me eventually. So, I also I I hold a small municipal elected position in my
  303. community as well. So, um, I was having a conversation with some of my commissioners as well about this about
  304. um, school buses and I had to come clean and tell them I had never been on a school bus before. I did not understand
  305. what they were talking about. So, it comes up in different ways, right? People know that I'm homeschooled
  306. eventually, but it was never something I led with because of those stigma and stereotypes that exist. Um, however, I
  307. was able to in this job, which was just what a neat experience, right? >> No, it's so funny that you mentioned
  308. that because uh I was thinking about you you talked about kind of that do doing research into the numbers of what
  309. homeschoolers do after, right? And I and I I know for me when I got to college, I
  310. hid that I was a homeschooler. I did not want to be the weirdo homeschool kid that everyone was like, "He's gonna be
  311. antisocial and he's gonna be whatever." I just told people I went to private school because that's what my my mom had
  312. always told me growing up, hey, if you're out and you know, people ask you about your education or whatever. Not
  313. that we were really afraid of truency officers or anything like that, but um but she also didn't want us to get uh in
  314. trouble if we, you know, ran an errand for her or whatever during traditional school hours. Um and so she would always
  315. say just, you know, tell people you're in private school kind of a thing. And and usually usually people will look the
  316. other way like they're just kind of move on from it or whatever. And um and so anyway, so I just took that into college
  317. and so many of of my friends and the people who have been on the show previous similar deal. They're like, "I got out
  318. of it and then I never wanted to talk about it ever again." Um, and I had one lady on early on uh the show who she had
  319. not thought about it for many, many years. And it kind of like almost blacked it out that she was like a
  320. homeschool kid and uh and she's like and then it all started coming flooding back
  321. uh when she got connected to the show and things like that. And so it was interesting to talk to her because as we
  322. were talking I could see like it lighting up in her brain of like I remember this thing that happened and
  323. all these you know and she had just kind of removed all of that from her life is
  324. >> that's not a defining factor of who I am any longer. And so um so I wonder if
  325. that plays any role in in those numbers that you guys are pulling there. So so funny to then go into a job interview
  326. and it's like that's actually the selling point of of uh [laughter] getting the job is like hey this was me.
  327. Yeah. >> So, let's talk a little bit about like how how people like myself can get
  328. involved or at least like learn more about it. Like I know you guys have a website. I'm going to link it down
  329. below. It's uh responsible education. Is that what it is? No. >> Well, so it's actually if if you just
  330. use our abbreviation cr.org, you can get there. Um it's the Coalition for Responsible Home Education is what those
  331. is what those letters are. >> And so aside from that though, how can alumni get involved? what are you
  332. looking to you know what are you needing from us I guess that's that's the question there [laughter]
  333. >> yeah thank you yeah thank you for that so I mentioned like you know we do a lot
  334. of work in resources and creating resources we love hearing from alumni what would help them um in terms of
  335. research as well a lot of that research is alumni driven so if people connect to
  336. us and get on our lists you'll see um not just our projects but we are kind of a nexus of alumni for a lot of different
  337. researchers as well so um there's an archavist in Wisconsin who reached out to me because they she wants to capture
  338. stories of homeschoolers in Wisconsin. So, all of these really neat research projects kind of come through us. So, if
  339. alumni dial into what we're doing um and you know and join our mailing list, they'll have the opportunity to share
  340. their stories and kind of contribute to this larger methodological research that's happening across the country.
  341. homeschooling is the fastest growing education modality in the US right now. And alumni have the opportunity to be
  342. on, you know, kind of the inside of that research as it's happening. Um, and that
  343. alumni perspective and research is such a critical piece when we move into advocacy as well. Um so at the Coalition
  344. for Responsible Home Education, we firmly believe that um states should have additional oversight measures in
  345. place for children that are homeschooled um both in kind of the educational realm
  346. as well as the child welfare realm because um students have the potential to miss out not just on resources but
  347. frankly on safety measures as well. At CR we do advocate for we say more oversight. That can sound like a scary
  348. word, but I promise it's not a scary word. It's just um it's just kind of responsibility measures. We would love
  349. it if every state had um you know kind of an assessment process for homeschooled children. Um we think
  350. that's important because we've seen both from research and from our alumni stories that sometimes when homesooled
  351. children fall behind, there's no way to even catch that educational gap until it's until frankly it's it's too late.
  352. So, when we look at, you know, kind of some of the education, we would love to see um homeschoolers be able to access
  353. all of the same resources that public school kids can. I live in Michigan now. Um while I grew up in Dearborn, I live
  354. in a slightly more rural community now. And so, I know that the public school a lot of times it's the only way that in
  355. communities like mine, those resources exist. I know you mentioned working at a library. In some small towns in
  356. Michigan, the only library is the school library. And homeschoolers should have that access, too. So, we are advocating
  357. for laws that, you know, both educationally support and resource kind of support our homeschoolers. Um, the
  358. other side of what we do and while um and why some of this work is is is hard to hear as well is that we also are
  359. advocating for oversight measures that will keep kids safe. In in in 48 states, someone can be convicted of a violent
  360. crime against children and still be allowed to homeschool their own child. Um, in 49 states as well, if a family is
  361. in the middle of a of an active child welfare investigation, they can actually withdraw their student to be
  362. homeschooled. Um, that's an incredible safety risk, especially when the perpetrator is likely someone at home.
  363. Um, because homeschooling has become so deregulated. I mentioned in Michigan since 1996, but because of that
  364. systematic deregulation of homeschooling, we've removed a lot of safeguards for children who could be the
  365. victims of abuse and neglect. So when you hear kind of shocking statistics, right, that you can be convicted of a
  366. crime against a child um and you and you can homeschool your own your own child,
  367. they won't have that same access and support during the day and that relief that they would have um if they were
  368. outside of the school system. So when we're talking to legislators, we're also talking about some very scary but very
  369. impactful work as well. And to be frank, we need alumni at the table. Um most homeschooling policy and law um is
  370. legislators who have never been homeschooled and will never homeschool their own children talking to parents
  371. who are actively homeschooling. And the place that we are not talking is people who have the lived experience of being
  372. homeschooled. Um and it's crazy to me that some of these decisions are made by people who have never been a
  373. homeschooled child themselves. They're not even taking feedback from homeschooled children. Um, and you can't
  374. do that when a when a homeschool child's like 12 or 13 because they're still under, you know, they're still within
  375. the experience. But when alumni dial into us, we can give them those opportunities to make their voice heard
  376. in a really impactful um way. >> That's huge. And that's honestly what I think was so attractive to your
  377. organization when I found it was was that because that is the piece that's missing. Um, and that's something that I
  378. when I started this show, it started very much from a selfish selfish place of like, hey, I just want to reconnect
  379. with my old friends and like, you know, kind of shoot the breeze on like old funny stories of like being moms and
  380. being weird little church homeschool kids and, you know, all that all that kind of stuff. And what I what I
  381. realized really quickly was that like we had these stories that yeah, we have the
  382. funny stories and we have like the great times and stuff, but we also have all these stories of like this was really
  383. good, this was really bad, and this over here, this was really ugly. Um, and those stories are important because like
  384. you said, they're going they can impact the next generation of homeschool kids. What I didn't realize when I started
  385. this show was who completely would be listening to it. I thought this is going to be like a therapy group. Only ex-h
  386. homeschool kids are going to listen to it. And the number of emails and DMs that I've gotten from active homeschool
  387. families who are saying, "Please keep doing this because I need to hear the stories of these kids so that I don't do
  388. the same thing to my kid." That's important. And and what you guys are doing is kind of a I think a furthering
  389. of that of just like, okay, but now we can actually make some laws based on those experience hopefully. Um, and
  390. that's very important. So, thank you for what you do. I appreciate it. Um, is there any legislation currently that's
  391. kind of in the works or that you guys are actively working on that people should be aware of and in what what
  392. states would those be happening? >> Yeah. So, we um legislatively we kind of work in we kind of work in two
  393. directions. So sometimes um sometimes there will be active um active legislation on the floor in different
  394. states where there's a great opportunity to bring homeschooling into this when things already exist and we can just
  395. kind of add some language about homeschooling into it. We're allowed um you know that that opportunity. Some of
  396. the current bills on the floor um one of them is in New Jersey. It's in actually
  397. in committee right now. And what's happening in New Jersey is that there's legislation that would require
  398. homeschool families um to check in once a year with their local school district.
  399. We firmly support this from both an educational uh you know kind of educational assessment component, but
  400. also to make sure that every every single homeschooled child in New Jersey would have access to a mandated reporter
  401. at least once a year. So when there is legislation happening like that like like that legislation in New Jersey, um
  402. we're firmly supportive of it. We activate our alumni around it to to to be supportive of the lawmaker who's kind
  403. of bringing that forward and we offer any kind of really any kind of support that we can. Um I hinted at it earlier,
  404. but the deregulation and the kind of anti-oversight homeschool homeschool movement is massive and it is far better
  405. funded than we are and their lobbyists are um you know far far better resourced uh than we are. But it's important that
  406. there's a but that there's another voice at the table. So right now where there's
  407. some of that active, you know, positive legislation on the floor um that's happening that's happening right now in
  408. New Jersey, but pretty close to that in Massachusetts. There's a bill in committee right now that will
  409. essentially remove the the few protections that there are in the state of Massachusetts from for homeschooled
  410. children. What they're looking to do in Massachusetts is actually Massachusetts does have a registry system, which means
  411. that if families are going to homeschool, they have to at least notify their local school board. What's
  412. currently on the floor in Massachusetts is the option to totally remove that. So, we would essentially be losing
  413. losing track of all of these kids. Same idea. We'll activate the alumni. The other the other reason the legislation
  414. happens and why people reach out to us is is a little bit darker. There are a lot of times there are really horrific
  415. cases that come that come into the public eye and that's what motivates legislators to start acting. Um I wish
  416. we would look at everything proactively, but that's just not the way it works. An
  417. example of that would be in Connecticut. I just realized I've used all New England examples. There's more states,
  418. but I just went through New England. Um so in Connecticut, um so in Connecticut right now, there will be some
  419. legislation coming to the floor that we are actively involved in. um in in in drafting right now because there have
  420. been um there have been two fatalities that surround uh what we what we would call suspicious withdrawal. This is when
  421. families have are actively engaged in a CPS investigation. They're allowed to take their kids out of school. Um and
  422. ultimately in both of these cases uh the children the children were murdered. So
  423. we are we are we are supporting that kind of drafting of legislation to to see when that comes. So, those are three
  424. states with active things happening right now. Um, but but we're also working directly with directly with
  425. legislators in multiple other states as well. So, even though I only named New England ones, faults of mine there,
  426. there's lots of others. >> Hey, you're you're all good. I know on the on the website as well, you guys
  427. have a have some cool like maps that, you know, you can put in the state you were educated in or the state you live
  428. in and things like that and it'll show you some of the the protections and and and the protections that don't exist in
  429. those states. Um, and that was helpful for me because up until like I said a couple years ago, like I didn't really
  430. realize the difference of um of really like each state. I just kind of thought like, hey, every every state is like,
  431. you know, my state of California. My parents just seem to I mean, I know they filed paperwork, but like they seem to
  432. just kind of like pull me out of school and homeschool me and um you know, and and do their best um so to [laughter]
  433. speak. >> And that's the case in 19 states is that all the parents have to do is well,
  434. actually, they don't even have to file paperwork in 19 states. California is when they actually have to file
  435. something. In 19 states, all that it is is if a child stops showing up to school, the parent says, "We're
  436. homeschooling." And that is truly the end of the road. >> Yeah. To your point, then it becomes
  437. very easy for kids to fall off the radar and to we hear stats all the time about
  438. homeschool kids being smarter and being more likely to succeed in the world and go do big things. U but I found it very
  439. interesting where some of those stats come from uh in more in more recent times. So, um, yeah. No, I I appreciate
  440. what you do and again to the audience, go check out what CR is doing. Um, link will be down in the show notes and get
  441. involved if you feel interested. Tess, is there anything we haven't touched on that you think is important regarding
  442. any of these topics? >> No, I'm I'm I'm grateful this show exists and to find these other, you
  443. know, networks networks of homeschool alumni. Um, I would definitely encourage alumni to, like you said, Jacob, get
  444. involved uh with what we're doing. um you know, positive, negative, and everywhere in between. It's really the
  445. voice of homeschool alumni that that is going to make the best uh the best case in not just in legislation, but in
  446. research and in resources for the next set of homeschooled kids. And I'm interested to see what, you know, what
  447. what stereotypes exist of them, right? I know I know the stereotypes that exist of homeschoolers around my generation.
  448. And I'm so curious what that's going to look like in, you know, 1015 years. So, we can talk about that then. [laughter]
  449. >> Yeah. No, I think it is I think it is really interesting because um like I know people who were kind of like in the
  450. bo the the front lines of the homeschool movement in California and their their stereotypes are different than like I'm
  451. more of a product of like the 2000s. Uh I was born in the '9s but homeschooled in the 2000s and the 2010s. Um and then
  452. now even knowing kids that are yeah in the 2020s uh being homeschooled and I'm like you you got a whole another set of
  453. weirdness on you. I joke with one of my friends I that we uh homeschoolers have this uh we have a
  454. smell to us and we can we can sniff each other out in a crowd pretty quickly. So
  455. uh >> yeah and my staff and I we say you know we say weirdo uh we say weirdo with all
  456. the positive connotation that there is. Right. >> Same. Yes. >> And we all identify with that.
  457. [laughter] >> Everybody everybody is weird. But like we have a there's a specific homeschool
  458. weirdo that is like and I and uh I think uh going back to kind of some of those previous comments of like uh I was
  459. ashamed of that for a number of years and now I feel like I've just em I've chosen to embrace that uh in my life of
  460. like this is a part of who I am and I I'm I'm not going to run from it anymore. So
  461. >> yeah, >> again, Tess, thank you so much for coming on and sharing your experience
  462. and what you do and and how others can get involved. Um, I'm looking forward to continuing like watching what you guys
  463. are doing, being involved how I can and uh, yeah, this has been this has been fantastic. Thank you again.
  464. >> Awesome. Thanks so much. I appreciate it. >> Awesome. And to you, my ex-homies, I
  465. hope you enjoyed this episode. Like we said so many times in this episode. Links will be down in the description to
  466. get involved with the coalition of responsible home educators and uh, see what see what's going on there. See if
  467. that's something you're interested in being a part of. If you want to hear more about it, let me know. Um, I'm
  468. happy to reach out to more of the people on their staff and see if they would want to come on and share some
  469. additional things. But yeah, and if you've got a homeschool story, don't be afraid to reach out to me. It's
  470. [email protected]. Shoot me an email, let me know. Give me like the quick little elevator pitch of
  471. who you are, uh, your homeschool experience, and let's let's chat. Let's see if you'd be a good fit to come on
  472. the show. Until next time, we'll see you. [music] Peace. >> [music] [music]

Brief Summary

Tess shares her homeschooling journey and discusses the Coalition for Responsible Home Education's advocacy for oversight and support for homeschooled children.

Key points

  • The Privilege of Homeschooling. Homeschooling is often seen as a privilege, but it comes with risks and challenges.
  • Tess's Homeschool Journey. Tess shares her unique experience of being homeschooled and its impact on her life.
  • The Shift to Unschooling. Tess discusses how her family's approach to homeschooling evolved over time.
  • Struggles in College. Tess reflects on the challenges she faced transitioning from homeschooling to college.
  • The Importance of Nonprofit Work. Exploring how nonprofit organizations like the YMCA and Boys and Girls Club provide essential support.
  • Navigating Homeschooling Privilege. A discussion on the privilege associated with homeschooling and its implications.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes