Why I Deconstructed My Faith | EXHS #21
Ask about Ex-Homeschoolers Club
Episode Description
I'm always striving to make this show better and I want to hear from you. If you've got a few minutes, would you mind answering a few questions? https://exhsclub.beehiiv.com/forms/ecd981ec-ed4e-4b22-a15d-ae3b2858c757
In this deeply personal episode, I open up about my journey of faith, doubt, and discovery. Reflecting on the intersection of my Christian upbringing and homeschooling experience, I share the struggles I faced reconciling my beliefs with hard questions, and how I eventually found the courage to embrace agnosticism. This year-end reflection is my raw and heartfelt exploration of identity, community, and the ongoing search for truth. Themes include my childhood faith, deconstructing religion, and rebuilding community after stepping away from traditional beliefs.
Key Takeaways: - The Foundation of Faith: Growing up in a devout Christian household shaped my early worldview. - Critical Turning Points: I wrestled with the Bible’s literal interpretations and observed inconsistencies within the church. - Community and Loss: Leaving church life brought challenges of isolation and rebuilding my sense of identity. - Deconstruction Journey: I moved from evangelical Christianity to agnosticism by questioning and exploring my beliefs. - Encouraging Open Dialogue: I now embrace curiosity and strive to foster respectful conversations about belief and doubt.
Resources Mentioned - Dirty Rotten Church Kids: https://www.instagram.com/dirtyrottenchurchkids/?hl=en - Ear Biscuits Deconstruction: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1qbna6t1bzw&list=PLLxmqs8vQskUbE_KnXQhA2gXmEg5dVMp3 - Ken Ham vs. Bill Nye: https://www.youtube.com/live/PPLRhVdNp5M?si=HC8GrldP_zzkYmWl - The New Evengelicals: https://www.thenewevangelicals.com/about/
Timestamps 00:00 Introduction and Year-End Reflections 00:20 The Gooden Family December Episodes 00:42 Sharing My Christian Journey 01:36 Gratitude and Listener Engagement 03:42 Nervousness and Vulnerability 05:34 Early Christian Experiences 11:05 Church Involvement and Music 16:04 Transition to Reality Church 27:25 College and Faith Challenges 31:31 Reconciling Evolution and Faith 32:01 Overwhelmed by Religious Commitments 33:21 Questioning Biblical Literalism 34:26 Exploring Different Perspectives 36:40 Burnout and Leaving Church 39:13 Deconstructing Faith 49:59 Embracing Agnosticism 53:21 Building a New Community 59:10 Final Thoughts and Future Plans
If you enjoyed this conversation, be sure to subscribe, leave a review, and share it with a friend who might benefit from hearing this story. Follow Ex-Homeschoolers Club on Instagram and TikTok for updates, and send us a message – we’d love to hear from you!
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/exhsclub/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@exhsclub Email me at [email protected]
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- happy holidays my ex- homies it's your friend Jacob Gooden the host of the best ex- homeschooler podcast this side of
- the internet that is the ex- homeschoolers club and man oh man we are winding down 2024 this is the last
- episode of the year I'm so stoked for it you got me today it's going to be a solo
- episode I told you that December was the month of the goodin and I'm delivering okay so first week of December you got
- an interview with my mom second week you got an interview with my dad and here we
- are in the third week you're getting an interview with me then we're taking a week off cuz we're going to
- celebrate Christmas and um so what are we going to talk about today what am I sharing
- well today I'm sh sharing my religious experience my Christian Journey um if you will and I really wrestled with this
- episode because when I started this podcast I really felt like yeah we're going to
- touch on faith and religion a little bit we have to right but I didn't never really want to share my story not
- because I'm ashamed of it or anything like that but I just kind of wrestled with it and The more I've done this show
- The more I've realized that my religious experience is so tied into my homeschool Journey that I would
- be doing myself a disservice and I'd be doing you guys a disservice if I didn't explain the things that I believed
- during my homeschool time and then now as an adult the things that I believe today so
- we're going to do that but before we do uh I got a couple things first and foremost I wanted to say thank you if
- you've been a listener a watcher a commenter uh somebody who's followed me on social media thank you so much you've
- made this show what it is today it's been far greater of an experience than I could ever imagine I really thought the
- show would do nothing I think that's what every podcaster says when they get started is that they they can't imagine
- their show actually uh getting views and and listens um but this show has definitely done so much more than even
- just that right those are vanity numbers but the connections the the reconnections I've made with people
- right and and the new connections with other homeschool kids have been absolutely amazing so thank you thank
- you thank you so much I I can't tell you words can't even describe how grateful I
- am for each and every one of you truly that being said I've got a favor to ask actually two one is that if you
- like the show and you listen to it on the regular maybe you share it with a friend you know send it their way during
- this holiday season say hey you've got some time I know you've got some time CU it's holiday break uh take a listen see
- what you think maybe reconnect with some old homeschool friends and um yeah do that if you wouldn't mind I would
- greatly appreciate it the second thing is I want to hear from you guys I want to know how I can continue to make the
- show better um I want to know guests that you want to have on topics you want to discuss I want to know if we were to
- build a community outside somewhere whether it's Reddit or Discord or slack or I don't know WhatsApp something like
- that um I want to know so I have a quick survey it's going to be the top Link in
- the description in the show notes whatever it's going to be down there somewhere okay just click down there
- okay and uh it's six questions okay it's super easy one of them is your email which probably will AutoFill in the
- second one is your name super easy and then I've got a couple questions about stuff about the show so if you don't
- mind fill that out for me I greatly greatly appreciate it it helps me so much and uh yeah so those are the my two
- favors the third thing I wanted to say before uh we get started is that I'm really nervous uh about this
- episode it's been a lot harder to prep for this episode than I think any other episode that I've done including the
- Purity culture one and I know Purity culture touched a lot on religion but um this one is just much more personal
- because it's my experience and I know that when you share your religious experiences on the
- internet it opens you up to criticism when you share anything on the internet it opens you up to criticism it opens
- you up to hate it opens you up to people being allowed to say whatever they want
- about you and so I have I have wrestled with that um I've shared some of my religious stuff online
- before and I've had hurtful comments thrown my way and I don't know it's just it it's been something that's been scary
- for me I guess is what I'm trying to say so I guess my third favor that I have to
- ask is that if you do want to comment and you do want to engage with this like please be loving be gentle be kind um
- you know this is my corner of the internet and I do reserve the right to if you're going to be mean and hateful
- like you will get blocked I I don't care I'm open to having discussion and I'm open to disagreement um what I'm not
- open to is hate just being thrown for Hate's sake so um yeah I don't know really how else to
- say that I I don't expect there to be hate but you know you never know I guess that's what I'm trying to say so enough
- of me stalling I guess let's kind of get into my story and man this is a lot harder than I expected so
- where does my Christian Journey begin let's let's start there I guess so growing up I I I remember always
- going to church I have my Christian my my parents are Christians um they they were they are um Christians they still
- go to church to this day and so I just remember going to church that was just a consistent thing in my life for pretty
- much my entire life and I want to say when I was around the age of between 6 and 8 and I know my parents can probably
- uh confirm or deny if this is correct or not but um my there was a Billy Graham crusade that came to town somewhere and
- my my dad took me and my sister and my grandpa and we went to this Billy gram Crusade now um a part of the biligram
- organization they have uh salty the singing song book and he is basically or they are I'm not even
- sure what salty is but uh salty is basically Barney Christian ified I guess um it's
- this gigantic book with arms and legs and eyes um that dances around and sings songs and it's yeah it's basically
- Christian Barney um for lack of a better term but at the end of the show they did
- an alter call and I remember tugging on my dad's shirt and I and saying Hey I want to go down there um and I want to
- accept Jesus into my heart and so we did and he took me down there and one of the
- team uh members that was down there kind of walked me through the ABCs of becoming a Christian and um which is to
- uh a is to admit um your sins B was to to uh accept and believe in Jesus Christ uh and C was confess uh your faith uh in
- Jesus's Savior and Lord and so I remember vividly doing that and I remember I don't I don't even like I
- can't again it's so vivid In My Memory it's hard to even describe I just remember being a can and doing this and
- really believing for the first time ever that I was like I'm a Christian I believe in Jesus and
- um so yeah so that happened and I won't say that much changed in my life like I still just went to church and Sunday
- school and did church activities and things like that and so I don't like I said I don't really remember it changing
- a whole lot did VBS and um I was just like a normal Church kid right and so during that time it was just kind of
- like I guess building the foundation of my faith right I read the Bible and do Bible studies with friends and and all
- that kind of stuff and so a few years later past that I want to say between eight and 10 years old uh is
- when I got baptized and again my choice my parents never forced me to do any of this
- um but I chose to get baptized in that is you know you presenting to your church saying I I'm choosing to live a
- Christian lifestyle and you know I want to walk with God basically and uh so yeah so I remember doing that I at the
- time we went to a little Baptist Church in the oh Valley and yeah was like a little dunk tank and Pastor put me under
- asked me a couple questions CH and came out and you know the church applauded kind of a thing there's really two main
- churches when I talk and think about my faith Journey that stand out to me and I
- attended more churches than this but there's really two that were like I think the backbone
- for my Christian my Christian experience and so that is Ohio Valley Baptist um as
- I said and I went there pretty much I was a young kid when we started go in there and I went there till I was about
- 14 13 14 years old um and then I went to reality Ventura um through high school and then into some college and
- so they shaped me in a lot of ways into into who I am today and into my Christian experience and so um I said
- this before but ohigh Valley Baptist was kind of I would say where the foundation
- of my Christianity comes into play um and then reality was like the place where I feel like I made my faith my own
- and and and I'll explain what that means in just a second but so oh Baptist built
- like it was the the foundation in that I was being taught the Bible um I was being taught very traditional
- Christian values um you know go to church read my Bible go home read my Bible um one of
- the big things I remember learning there was like the import importance of serving um and that being a huge part of
- of Christianity is like serve other people right love other people serve them and I I saw that played out through
- like my parents and and other people inside the church my parents were like the treasures at the church and I want
- to say that they like LED Bible studies at different points and all this kind of
- thing and and so being the good little Christian boy that I was I wanted to mimic that I wanted to you know emulate
- that in a lot of ways and um and so that meant a lot of things right cleaning up around the church um
- it meant you know playing guitar um uh with the worship team uh it meant like serving like doing uh sound or like
- helping with aana and like all these things and um being just very much involved in
- church activity I guess and uh I was a big time music nerd I think around the age of 10 I my parents can confirm or
- deny this but around the age of 10 is when they told me that I had to learn an instrument and I picked guitar and so I
- spent like eight plus oh no it was more than that I spent close to a decade playing guitar and you know so by the
- time I was 12 I think I'd been playing for two plus years at that point I was starting to get asked to serve uh in
- church on the worship team and play like special music and stuff like that and I
- loved it I loved it so much um I can't even tell you how much it was just like it was amazing it was it was what I
- wanted to do um and it was interesting because the church again we're going to oh Baptist
- at this time it's very conservative traditional old school Church a lot of hymns uh we mostly had organ and piano
- uh worship So guitar was kind of a new mix the the worship as at the time was trying to contemporize it a little bit
- that's not even a word but we were trying to play more contemporary Christian music um you know most of the
- people there were okay with the fact that like you know I could get up there and play cusa guitar with him and and it
- sounded good and things like that but uh but as I got older got an electric guitar the the worship Pastor wanted to
- kind of like make it more contemporary right so you know let's put some electric guitar in the mix and we had a
- bass player at church and he was trying to find a drummer and all these things and I just vividly remember like after
- church one week and like uh a church member coming up to me and basically telling me that like I was too loud and
- my electric guitar was too loud and that basically like rock music didn't have a
- place in church and I was like really crushed I think as a kid because I that was what spoke to me right like that was
- when we if you've read the Bible you know that music is pretty pretty big in the Bible especially in the Old
- Testament is there's a lot of I there's a whole freaking book in the Bible that's just songs and so I would read
- these things and and I felt like music music is this Escape for the soul right it is this
- connection to something bigger than ourselves ideas beliefs whatever it is not to get too woo woo with it but like
- it connects you to to bigger things and so it was hard for me to hear that because
- here I was 12 13 years old really wanting to like pursue a really healthy relationship
- with God and music was a way that I connected I felt like I connected with God and so to be told that that like
- basically has no place in church was just tough right it was just not not what I wanted um to hear um
- and and really it was coming from old people who they were just stuck they were just
- stuck in they wanted to hear hymns and they wanted what they wanted and and I think it was it was tough too if you
- have ever been to a Baptist Church you know that they tend to be um I don't know if political is the the
- correct word here but they tend to be like this Democratic process at least ours was we voted on freaking everything
- and I remember this again a very distinct memory this is ultimately I think what
- really turned me off to going to church there was we had a meeting of the church
- members and we were asked I was young right I was 13 at the time and like being asked like well what is what about
- church would draw more young people we needed more young people at the church that was what we were trying to solve
- and and they asked me because I was 13 and I said well I want louder music I want rock and roll right I want pastors
- who are like you know like fun I want uh children's church was always kind of a mess at our church
- because it was I don't know I felt like there wasn't enough young adults or even
- sometimes kids to Warrant always having uh Sunday school and things like that but um yeah just
- like I remember saying that and then just kind of being shot down and being like H that's not it like don't listen
- to him it's like well okay so I say I say that to that gets us to church number two that gets us to reality is
- basically what I'm getting at and so around that time of 13 I think it was a summer I was I was going to turn 14 I
- was going to freshman year high school and uh my best friend at the time he invited me to go to youth group with him
- and I was like okay my church didn't have a youth group because there was hardly any youth there and so I go
- reality it was amazing it was like everything I could have dreamed for right music was loud it was rock and
- roll the pastor was relatable uh you know we played fun games everybody was cool like and I remember being like if
- Sunday is anything like this then like this is the kind of church I want to go to
- and it was like I remember just being so like I was in love with it I was just instantly in love with it right I felt
- like I could finally have a community of people who could push me towards being a
- better Christian right and who we just related right we could be strong together you know the
- Bible always says the Bible says um that like multiple cords together are are stronger right and it's like a rope and
- so I remember going to my parents and kind of being like hey I'm really fed up at ohigh Valley um I'm just like I'm
- just kind of like dying I I don't like going I don't look forward to going on Sundays I don't feel like I can even
- serve because just get told I'm doing it wrong all the time um I want something new right and I'm really thankful that I
- had I had parents who they listened and they didn't judge um but they heard me and and I think my sister was kind of
- echoing some of the same things I was and so they listened to us and they said okay like let's let's try something
- different and they were heavily involved in that church um and so they definitely
- it took a little while cuz they had to and their commitments there but they were like okay let's let's go to some
- other churches and so I think we went to like two churches we had decided as a family we're going to tour a couple
- churches and go a couple weeks and and you know feel it out make pros and cons lists and whatever else and decide and I
- think we went to two churches and then we were like reality is the place and I was stoked my friends were there um like
- I said I just felt like it was it lit a new fire inside of me for Christianity and reality is the place I feel
- like I made my faith my own and what do I mean by that I I think it's been hard to Define it to be
- honest and I'm looking at my notes because I'm like what did I write down to kind of explain this
- and the way I always viewed Christianity in our relationship with God was through
- this lens of relationship right it's a personal relationship between you and God right and so prayer is the way that
- you talk to him and prayer doesn't always have to be the Super formal like dear God um you know whatever it could
- just literally be a conversation that's just how I view it that's that was my understanding of of of God right and how
- things worked and so I always viewed it as this personal relationship thing and and that
- God was was there and there was there was rules and there was expectations and there was
- um there was kind of this the Bible was not a rule book so to speak but a guidelines I guess um of like here's
- what following me looks like and and if you struggled with it you talk to God about it and then you'd also talk to
- your fellow Christians about it and be like how can I be better at this right right so when we got to reality I felt
- like I finally had that I had people around me who I was going to a church of people who allowed children to speak
- that that that is a key point that I wanted to say as well Ohio Val Baptist for me felt like a church where children
- were kind of still these things that were like to be seen and not heard and that's not 100% true but it definitely
- felt it it definitely there was a generation of people at that church who were kind of like they would not ignore
- knowled that the kids had these like spiritual needs um so to speak whereas reality it felt like that
- was a huge part of their Ministry um was making sure that kids were seen and heard um and and given like tools right
- and so so going to reality I got really tied into the youth group I got really tied into like serving I was on the
- worship team I helped with the sound team um doing PowerPoint like uh I went to junior high camp with kids uh as like
- a a leader like I did I think what I felt like was good Christian boy Behavior so you know um I
- was serving I was serving others inside of the church um to be honest I don't know that I was serving many people
- outside of the church who arguably are the people who need it more but I was serving people in inside the church um
- and and living in community with people who were strengthening me were backing me up on things I
- believed um that kind of a thing and so where do I want to go from here let me check my notes again I told you guys
- this was a hard episode for me to like put because there's so many thoughts and there's so many nuances there so many
- rabbit holes I could go down and talk for hours about this stuff um so now let me look
- here okay I think this is important to share I would argue that I have friends from that time who would who would say I
- maybe wasn't the most Evangelistic person um you know Christianity calls us to spread religion to all to spread the
- message of Christ to all corners of the Earth right and some people are much more charismatic and um able to like go
- do that and be missionaries and all those kind of things I was I've never really been that
- way um I build long lasting relationships and friendships and with people who are like my writer
- dies um and again this comes back to my interpretation of the Bible and things I
- read about and I I have always felt like the Bible shows us that people have different
- skills and to lean into your skills right and that there's a place for you at the table and so I always felt like
- my place was not evangelism um in the sense of like let me go out on the streets and just
- talk to people and like lead them to Christ right there on the street like evangelism for me was again relationship
- right I talked about my relationship with God was very personal was very one-on-one um
- or one on Three if you believe in the Holy Trinity that's also kind of how I viewed like evangelism right is this
- oneon-one relationship with people and I felt like you could always go so much further if you just had genuine
- relationship with people and so I remember when I was in college I interned at my dad's office and I I had
- like data entry it was like the worst job in the world um so boring but popping a podcast asked do my work and
- be done but uh one day I'm having lunch and this woman who I had met her before but I I didn't know her very well comes
- in and I'm sitting there and I'm you know I'm eating lunch alone I'm like on my phone scrolling and she comes over
- and she asks if she can sit with me and talk with me and I was like okay sure and we started talking and she's she's
- like um oh you're you're Keith's son right and I was like yeah and um and she goes yeah you guys are just like
- different aren't you and I was like what I was like kind of taking it back because I was just like what that's like
- kind of rude to say and she's like I don't mean it in a rude way I just mean it in a like there's something about you
- guys that's like different and like special and again this doesn't sound great right but um but what she was so we so
- we started talking and and what it really boiled down to was she she felt this like that we were genuine people who
- genuinely connected and I was like okay and she's like yeah when you see me you always say
- hello and you ask me how I am and if feels like you actually like give a [ __ ] about me as a person and you're
- listening to what I have to say and things like that and I was like oh interesting and she's like why do you
- think that is like why do you think you are that way or like how are you that way and I was and at the time I was a
- Christian still and so I said I said well I'm a Christian and and a part of my religion is is that it's caring for
- people right it's it's being there for them it's actually like giving a [ __ ] about them and I didn't really push it I
- was like you know I wasn't about to be like oh you should come to church with me or like I don't know what her
- religion was she could totally have been a Christian as well but like that's what
- I mean when I say that like for me evangelism is this relational thing where it's like if I had lunch with her
- again you know um we could either continue that conversation about genuine connection with people we could go down
- a more religious Rabbit Hole the door had been opened I guess so to speak again that's just how I've always viewed
- it it's relationship it's genuinely caring about people that's that's how I viewed Christian and evangelism and
- so that's kind of a side tangent um of this whole thing but again trying to give you guys an understanding of my
- belief system right and I guess I didn't make it very clear um Christianity for me what that meant what I believed in
- was that God created the world Seven Days Seven Nights um on that seventh day he
- rested said he created Adam and Eve who were the first man and woman uh they messed up and they sinned which is why
- we've all fallen short and for many many years um God worked in these mysterious
- ways he built the nation of Israel um all of these things uh and then thousands of years
- later um he came and spoke to a woman named Mary Mary had uh was a virgin and she gave birth to a son that is the Son
- of God Jesus Christ and um and he grew up to be the savior of the world he died the Ultimate Death
- uh on a cross to pay for our sins and so that is what I'm talking about when I talk about Christianity for me those
- were the things I believed in again that's very glossed over um there's a lot more Nuance to it but I'm trying to
- keep it brief guys I know I'm running long here but so where are we College let's talk
- about college okay so After High School reality was amazing reality like I said I felt like it gave
- me a place to make my faith my own really and and serve people and so when I got to college
- I I chose a college it was a Christian college and also it was small and I did that because it was comfortable I was
- used to The Homeschool bubble and inside of that homes School bubble it felt like
- so many people we all believe the same thing right even though we had small disagreements on about some things and I
- think maybe bigger disagreements behind the scenes what I'm learning doing this podcast but um but for the most part we
- kind of believe the same thing we were all kind of in this bubble of Christianity homeschool weirdness type
- of thing and um so College I didn't want to Veer too much out of that I feel like
- I I I was already scared to leave home um and so I chose a school that was like was safe right it was Christian College
- you know there was actually a decent number of homeschoolers there um but it felt like that homeschool youth group
- bubble um still and so so I got there now this school was so Christian we had we had a
- lifestyle agreement so we were not allowed to drink uh we were not allowed to smoke we were not allowed to do drugs
- we were not allowed to uh have premarital sex uh we were not allowed to um just a prear we were also were not
- allowed to have like gay saxs um I'm trying to remember there was there was other things as well uh we had
- commitment to like being at Chapel a certain number of times every semester um it was not a requirement but it was a
- highly it was highly suggested that you join a church um that you be involved in
- like Bible studies and things like that and um which as somebody who was already
- kind of used to that kind of lifestyle of like going to church every Sunday going to youth group once a week uh
- serving in Ministry some other way during the week sometimes uh it was like normal to me and so when I got to school
- I just I very quickly I I didn't also really understand that there was certain things that were more like we want you
- to do this but we understand like it's not 100% possible so by the end of my first semester I found myself I was
- going to church like six times a week it was crazy um it was just a lot and It ultimately resulted in me kind of
- burning out of church I'll talk about that in a minute but the other thing that school was teaching me was it was
- really the first time too that I was in an environment where I took a religion class my first year um we talked
- about a lot about Christianity and the difference between you know what is a Baptist versus like Cath
- versus uh Wesleyan versus this and then all of the difference in between all that stuff and
- so so the first day of class the professor comes in and he's asking us all these questions right he's asking us
- about like the seven-day creation and he's asking us why we believe that he's asking us if we believe in Noah's Arc
- and could could the flood have not really been Global could it have been all these other things right and what he
- was trying to do I look back on it and I realize he was trying to push us to defend our faith
- um but I didn't have good answers for him to be quite honest I just had answers that were like well my pastor
- told me this and my like you know my parents told me this and my science textbook told me this and like all those
- kind of things um because yes I did do Christian Science and so I didn't have a strong understanding of even like what
- evolution was and later down the line in college I also took a science and uh religion
- class and that was like crazy because we talked about like how Evolution and the
- Bible can both be true we talked about like all of these things right that were just like I had always been like the Ken
- Ham boy right like I had just like watched so many Ken Ham videos and like was like bought into that whole thing
- and so to hear these opposing things was kind of like I don't want to say it like
- wrecked my faith because it didn't but it definitely opened me up to asking questions and being comfortable asking
- questions and being like okay well maybe I'm not so sure so all that to say let's go back to six
- days a week so going to church six days a week okay three chapels a vbr service um uh church
- on Sunday and then usually a college group uh of some kind that was like off-campus so four oncampus things two
- off-campus things and I mean I was like serving hard and these things I mean that that that
- church was like a startup church I got plugged in like literally the first week of school maybe the second week of
- school um we would build this whole church on Sunday morning inside of a movie theater do worship run sound
- whatever I needed to do like help tear it all down put it all away in storage like it I don't know um it was just
- doing what I thought I was supposed to do right was just serve um and yeah and then ch cple three times a week like
- that gets really hard um for anybody who's done College you know that like coursework is just really hard sometimes
- it's really heavy it was a lot it was a lot and it it resulted in me just getting to a point where I was like I
- need time for myself I needed time for me um which I think is really healthy and really normal for a lot of people so
- I just kind of burned out now let's jump back into the questioning right the classes
- right so I have these professors in college who are asking me questions about like Noah is Arc and if it's real
- and how much of the Bible is Parable and how much is truth and how much is historically accurate and how do we back
- these things up right they're College professors they're just pushing us to answer questions that's just what they
- do right um and I can hear a couple people I just know the comments sometimes come when you start to like
- question those things right is like people do this like well that's where faith comes in stupid or like you know
- um you know you have to have faith things unseen and like how do we know this is true and you know all all those
- types of things but it was a thread that I wanted to pull right it was a thread I wanted to
- understand more and I wanted to kind of like I wanted to have a better understanding of like could you be a
- Christian and believe in evolution right so let's pull that thread could you be a
- Christian and believe that like the story of Noah Arc Noah's Arc is like not real okay you know pull those threats
- right and so just doing lots of research listening to shows listening to podcasts
- listening to scientists um I remember watching Bill NY uh on YouTube like in my room just over and over and over
- because I don't remember watching Bill n as a kid um and so hearing what he had to say and a lot
- of it's really cool I mean it's just science experiments it's you know how to blow up a balloon with you know mixing
- this with that and you know whatever else but it was really cool to like he these like differ opinions and start
- to like okay well why do they believe that where's the proof of that okay and then compare it to someone like a kenam
- one of the best things I think anybody can go watch if you grew up like me um if you grew up like me inside of like
- the creationism science bubble uh kenam has built an arc here in the it's like in the midwest I think it's in
- Kentucky or something like that um uh bill and I came and visited and they walked through together and they filmed
- the whole thing and they discussed it and they disagreed on things and um anyway I think it's really really cool
- or if you come from the perspective of like um more like an evolution creationism kind of um um creation
- Viewpoint I think it's interesting as well to hear Ken Ham's side of that so that's a little resources I think it's
- on YouTube but yeah go find it kenam and Bill NY debating it was really interesting so I also just had all these
- questions right and I go to church and and the thing about church is pastors speak with such conviction and such
- certainty sometimes and that can be really hard when you're someone who's doubting a lot of things because you're
- going okay I want to trust this person and I understand that for them they they firmly believe
- this but they don't always necessarily they're maybe not an expert in it you know they might also like I was just
- kind of be going off of well this is what my pastor taught me and this is what my parents told me was correct you
- know for a number of years and so it it just it was a lot it was a lot and and so I burned out I think I
- just had so much religion crammed into my head from all angles for those three years that I was in college that I just
- was like I can't do this anymore like I just need like it to stop it's like a voice in your head that will not shut up
- right and you're just like shut up um and the only thing I think I can compare it
- to is again in college I leading up to college I was an Avid Reader right I read like insane numbers of books um and
- that's not to to my own horn that's just the the reality of what it was like I read all of Little House in the prairie
- like in a week the whole series it's like seven books it's like a book a day it's crazy I like devoured books um my
- dad could not keep up when I read Lord of the Rings it was like sorry Dad I just you know it's like the flash racing
- against the turtle like it's you know um it was crazy so but when I got to college I could crank through textbooks
- so it was good like it was good I had that skill to be able to really get through things really quickly but by the
- time I got out I was just like I can't read any more books like I was just like burned out of this like thought books
- were terrible and it took a long time to really get back the spark of like okay books I can read again here we are
- now 2024 and I'm finally like really reading again I've read books but I'm just like really avidly reading um so
- it's been a while I graduated in 2017 so it's it's been a number of years to fully get it
- back now okay so also when I talk about like burning out of church that was not me
- leaving religion it was not me being like I'm no longer a Christian nothing like that it was just it was just me
- leaving church I was like I I it's too much of a commitment for me to do right now
- where I couldn't go to church and not feel like I had to serve and I knew I needed to be I I had had lunch with a
- pastor who had said you just need to be in a time of like receiving like you you've poured out a lot and now you need
- to be in a time of receiving and so I just quit I quit going to church um I still read my Bible I still identified
- as a Christian um but things were like changing right like I said like I was I was in addition to reading the Bible I
- was also starting to read these other books and I was starting to listen to uh experts right scientific experts and
- like um kind of figuring out what I believed right and this ties into like so what finally
- made me like call it quit quits with Christianity and there's two parts to this there's there's the part of Christianity
- where I saw people inside of Christianity not treating other human beings like human beings um and just
- being hateful and disgusting to be quite honest and then the second part of that
- was as I continue to research and ask questions I got to a place where I didn't I couldn't believe the Bible was
- like accurate and was like truthful to be honest and so growing up the Bible was just it was the inherent
- word of God it was it was Perfection it was like you don't doubt it it is ultimate truth right if you ever wonder
- anything you could always rely on the Bible to be true and so when I began to question that and and
- again that came down to I started to realize that I was like I don't know that I believe in like a literal
- seven-day creation I believed in like something different I was like yeah I can explain it inside the Bible but to
- me it was like Evolution over courses of time but God is a part of it and God has
- a hand in it and and it is seven days technically but it's not seven days it's millions of years or you know whatever
- like I started to have these differing opinions on what the Bible was saying there's this thing that
- pastors love to do if you've been to church you know you know what I'm talking about pastors do
- this thing where they go they talk about like the word love for instance and they
- go in the you know if you look back at the Greek or the Hebrew of of this you know book right Book of Matthew or
- whatever it's this word uh in that and that can mean it's it's this like undying love right they go deep on like
- it's this word that's bigger than the word that been translated to and um one that's like kind of cringey
- not going to lie sorry it is um but two uh I started to kind of like be interested
- in understanding like how is the bible translated right so I started listening to these podcasts
- with with guys who had worked on these committees that would translate the Bible and rewrite them and so like how
- is the you know why does the NLT different than the nsv and why is it different than King James and like who
- is choosing to translate these into English and then like are we taking the English translation and translating that
- into other languages or are we taking the original Hebrew and Greek and translating that into different
- languages like how how does all this work how do we decide like new Bible translations and all these things right
- and so I highly encourage people and I'm going to try to find some some of the resources it's been a number of years
- since I went down some of this Rabbit Hole um but I'm going to try to find some of the resources and put them below
- just like people I I would listen to to kind of like understand where where these things come from and what
- what I was coming to what I was meeting being met with as I was researching this
- was like like the King James version for instance is like it's called the King James version because King James is the
- one who had it translated into English and he had a say in what went in the Bible right and why certain books are
- not included and why they are and you know again we have disagreements with other religions right Christianity and
- Judaism and uh Mormonism and latterday Saints they all kind of share similarities um and similar books we
- disagree on some things um people are not going to like that I just lumped all those together uh I don't blame you uh
- but but there is a shared commonality even Islam right there's a shared commonality sometimes with the readings
- of those texts and the understanding of those texts right and they just differ in you know books and things like that
- so anyway I uh I digress a little bit but the King James version and learning about that and really understanding what
- was going on and why was he doing this and how was he using his influence to twist what was being said in the Bible
- so he could do things that he wanted to do and so then you get to you start to question right again it goes back to
- this question you of like can I trust the Bible because it's obviously been [ __ ] up by man uh it's been it's been
- bastardized to be quite honest um and words that mean one thing have have taken on new meaning
- um you know it was it it's like in my grandpa's lifetime that like homosexuality even like entered the
- Bible um as far as like certain language goes right and that's crazy to me so I I don't know
- just like understanding where that translation came from really I think it blew the doors open uh for me to kind of
- be like I I really just question this a lot now to go back to that first thing I
- me was seeing Christians not act like Christians towards other people and this was
- something I had seen early early on in high school uh junior high even and I saw to myself
- um how do how do I want to say I when I was 13 to 15 we've talked about the red pants on the show we talked
- about the red pants how cringy they were I liked bright colored clothing okay I had pink shirts I had purple shirts
- purple was my favorite color it's been for a long time um I liked wearing bright colors um and when I was going to
- Hawaii Valley Baptist I would wear I had this like pink shirt and I had a couple
- other shirts that were they were just fun they had just fun patterns and they're bright and obnoxious and
- whatever and I remember this lady coming up to me after church and just blatantly
- asking me if I was gay and I was like no because being gay was a sin that's what
- I grew up believing and I was really like taking back I don't like I just remember saying no and then just like we
- moved on from that conversation it was just like over it was like a done deal but it sat with me for so long because I
- was like wait what like the way I dress makes me gay which felt weird and then also like if I
- was what like what were you going to do about it I I don't really know like and I don't know because that person I
- wasn't so there there was no action taken after that point but I say that to say that in high
- school and then especially in college I was around people who we didn't talk about these things when
- homosexuality came up it was like just kind of this like Abomination it was this thing that was just not okay um I
- don't think anybody was equipped to talk about it um and [Music] so so we just didn't we just didn't we
- made gay jokes and and stuff like that and we just yeah we just didn't to be quite honest and when I got college is
- when I really I think started to see like hatred towards lgbtq I saw racism for the first time I moved from
- California to St Louis area um right over the Border in Illinois and I was like two towns over from a
- town that had like an active clue clux clan um and would go shopping with like I went shopping with uh a friend who was
- black and like literally he got called like the n-word and like all kinds of things by just just white people and it
- was just wild it was just like this weird experience and again I know some people will say like oh well those
- people you don't know if they're Christians or not that's true to some degree but
- I saw what I started to realize was I saw the people around me who were quote unquote Christians right who claimed to
- to love God and and and want to emulate Jesus and everything that they do and then when it come to oh let's invite
- like you know this gay guy over they just like were super weird about it and super uncomfortable and they didn't want
- anything to do with that person and they struggled to like let them into any church type activity and like all these
- things and I just like I don't know it just gives you an icky feeling right it's just when you're reading the Bible
- and you read about the fact that like Jesus sat at a table with like the worst of the worst people and he had
- conversation with them and you know he laughed and they drank together and they hung out right not to say they were
- friends but they were friendly and I wasn't I didn't see that emulated and so it was just this massive turnoff
- to like Christianity um and then as I got older I started to see my friends that I had grown up with
- as they started [Music] to I I think we started to like sexually awaken to some degree um and come into
- our own and the people who who stepped into being gay or being bisexual or being a lesbian or or transitioning or
- whatever it was um how they were received by friends was like really apparent um it was apparent who the
- people were who were like yeah we're still friends let's go like let's have fun you know let me ask questions you
- know let me be inquisitive and try to understand better and know how to not be offensive right people were growing and
- then other people were just stuck in the same way of being like this is an Abomination and you know how could you
- ever be a Christian kind of a thing and so that's really those two things really
- I think they they put the nail in the coffin of me being like I don't I can't believe in this anymore um
- and I don't see this as healthy now I'm not here to judge and to say that you're one of those Christians
- um I know plenty of Christian people who I think are very loving um and and I know Christian people who are not I say
- all these this is my experience these are the things that I've seen in my life and
- and they're what got me to where I am today so what do I believe today I guess what what did this all lead to what did
- I eventually decide on I really for a while I think I went down the atheist rabbit hole and being like there is no
- God right and I don't sit there today I I I say that I'm agnostic and what I mean by
- that my definition is that I think I don't believe in the god of the Bible but I also don't
- I don't believe that there's like not nothing out there right like there's something bigger and
- and arguably greater than us out there I don't know if it's a God if it's Gods if
- it's aliens it's just like a different realm right different dimension the fourth
- dimension um yeah I don't know I don't know what it is and I'm like and I choose to be
- comfortable in that like in that questioning of like what is it what could it be right
- um uh there's a great Duo on YouTube uh R link um they have a podcast called earbiscuits and they did a whole series
- of their deconstruction journey and they do these checkups every year and they talk about things that they um have just
- learned and where they are where they sit um and one of them calls themselves uh a hopeful agnostic I guess is um the
- way he puts it and what he means by that is that he's like I kind of he's like I
- hope that there's something out there I hope that there's something bigger and then I think where I sit too it would be
- a lot easier for me to believe in the god of the Bible and to have kind of this certainty of like what happens
- after death and you know and if you're a good person you go to heaven and like all these things right it's like
- I I'm jealous honestly of people who have that still um cuz I don't and it's sometimes really scary the scary iest
- part for me when I decided to not be a Christian any longer was quite honestly telling my
- parents and I didn't think that they would abandon me or anything like that I just
- it was just hard I can only compare it to like somebody coming out to their parents and I know that's probably a
- terrible comparison and I'm sorry if uh if I'm offending you I I'm but as far as
- my understanding of just like the emotions that run through you when you do something like that it was like the
- one of the hardest things to sit down and be like I don't believe in this anymore and I know it made them
- sad um but it has opened up so many cool conversations to be had about just why things are the way they are
- right and why do we believe the things that we believe and we disagree on on a lot and that's okay
- um and I know that they pray for me every day um and I'm thankful for that but the thing that was important and the
- thing I was scared about when I came when I came out to them when I uh when I told them was the fact I I still even
- though I didn't think that they would just abandon me and like leave me out to dry R be say I want nothing to do with
- you I still there was still this like you know fear that I was losing that because one of the things that
- Christianity brings into your life and holds for you is this community it's like built-in Community
- that's what we do right as a church we live life together right that's like a thing that gets said a lot
- and when I left I just lost that I just like didn't have that anymore I didn't even feel safe around like a lot of the
- friends I had because they were still in it and I didn't know how they were going to react
- to that experience that that questioning right um I think what I really want this
- episode to nail home for people if anything one is one just get this off my chest but
- two I would hope that people would take from this that it's okay to question things
- it's okay to be different it's okay to believe different things and it's it's okay to like have discussion around it
- in a civilized way and to be open to the fact that like maybe I'm wrong or maybe do some
- research um in topics that you feel uncomfortable about and try to understand I think there's a lot of fear
- inside of Christianity inside of religion itself um about this like losing control right
- this like well if they start to pull like I talked about pulling the thread right
- following the thread it's like if if they start to do that then like the whole thing
- unravels um and I I just I think I disagree with that I don't think the whole thing on
- ravels and and it just changes is what it is and some people might end up like me right
- who are agnostic and other people might still remain Christians or Christ followers or or who knows maybe they'll
- go to other religions I don't really know but like I guess what I'm trying to say is
- like don't be scared to ask the dumb questions because and and and to ask hard questions and to be scared of asking
- questions like I I like it's okay it's okay to be scared of asking questions I would come home from like listening to a
- podcast about deconstruction and being like I think I believe this and it was terrifying for me I was like I don't
- want this I have journal entry after journal entry of being like I'm Losing My Religion and it's like terrifying to
- me um because I felt like I was losing everything I was losing my identity out of that had to come a new
- like building a new identity of who I was as a person and I I I think there's this
- fear no I know I don't think I know that there is this fear inside of churchgoers that when you lose your
- religion you lose the good part of you because we're told that it's only through God that you
- can do good things it's only because of this that you can do good things it's only because of you know
- whatever and I'm going to get a lot of shift for this but I'm going to say it anyways I
- choose to believe that people I grew up believing that people were inherently bad and they needed God to be good I
- have changed my stance on that and I believe that people are inherently good I believe that people
- are hurting and they make mistakes um but ultimately I think people want to do good and want to see
- other people succeed I don't know I could be wrong prove me wrong I'm trying to think where to wrap
- this to be honest I feel like I could go another tangent I feel like I'm a little
- spirally right now and I apologize for that I hope this has made sense um I guess that's what I'll leave it with I
- hope this this made sense um let me check my notes we're scrolling through we're asking
- okay I guess I'll leave you with this if this is you if you've got questions if you had significant shifts in your
- belief system like and you want to share them like it doesn't have to be on the show it can literally just be in private
- but if you I I would love to know I think I talked about losing the community element of church
- is really scary and it wasn't until honestly probably this year maybe last year a little bit that I started to
- really build that back this three plus years of me feeling isolated and alone and with no Community um and I'm
- building it back it's it's coming it's slow but it's it's coming and um yeah so just know if you feel like
- me uh You're Not Alone um and like I said if you have an experience a similar experience or your beliefs or your
- worldview are shifting or changing or being different or maybe they're the same I don't know and you want to talk
- about it let's talk about it I'm I'm always open so you can do that if you got questions about the show you got
- questions about me you got questions about whatever you know you can email me exhs [email protected]
- uh Instagram DMS are open exhs Club um let me know I want to I want to hear your stories I hope this wasn't too
- rambly I apologize if it was hopefully I can edit and clean it up and make it sound more polished but it's just Raw
- it's the real me it's the real me processing and thinking through these things and doing this show has opened up
- some of that can of worms again and so what I'm saying is I'm here I'm kind of on the other side of some of it some
- of the really hard nasty stuff of of losing my religion and I want to be there for you um if
- possible again I ask you if you got something to say if you disagree with me that's fine be kind right it it doesn't
- cost anything to be nice um if you want to have discussion around it let's do it
- um yeah okay I'm going to stop rambling I hope you guys have a very merry Christmas happy holidays if you
- celebrate any of the other holidays that are happening uh in this time of the year I hope you are with loved ones with
- friends with family with whatever it might be um and enjoy enjoy the season enjoy the time enjoy the break that
- we're going to take um if you're really really missing the show it's okay there's 20 other episodes you can go
- back and listen to um we're going to be back very very soon whole new cast of people we got 80s and 90s kids coming on
- I have an actual therapist coming on um I have a sex expert coming on um uh I've
- got homeschool kids from other parts of the country not just California coming on it's going to be fun we've got some
- really cool stuff planned for this upcoming year I hope you stick around I hope you hit that subscribe I hope you
- share the show with your friends and uh yeah so until next year this has been the exom schoolers club I'm your host
- Jacob goodon and we'll see you all right peace [Music] [Music]
Brief Summary
Jacob Gooden shares his Christian journey, challenges with faith, and current agnostic beliefs in a personal reflection on religion and community.
Key points
- Last Episode of the Year. Jacob reflects on the journey of the podcast and shares his personal story.
- Sharing My Christian Journey. Jacob opens up about his religious experiences and the impact of homeschooling.
- Invitation for Listener Feedback. Jacob asks listeners for their input on improving the show and community building.
- Evangelism Through Relationships. The speaker shares their belief that evangelism is about genuine relationships, not just outreach.
- Burnout from Church Commitment. After intense involvement in church activities, the speaker felt overwhelmed and needed a break.
- Questioning Biblical Accuracy. The speaker reflects on their journey of questioning the literal truth of the Bible.
Episode highlights
- Last Episode of the YearJacob reflects on the journey of the podcast and shares his personal story.“I'm so stoked for it!”0:15Dec 18, 2024
- Sharing My Christian JourneyJacob opens up about his religious experiences and the impact of homeschooling.“I really wrestled with this episode.”0:48Dec 18, 2024
- Invitation for Listener FeedbackJacob asks listeners for their input on improving the show and community building.“I want to hear from you guys!”2:52Dec 18, 2024
- Evangelism Through RelationshipsThe speaker shares their belief that evangelism is about genuine relationships, not just outreach.“I always felt like my place was not evangelism.”23:08Dec 18, 2024
- Burnout from Church CommitmentAfter intense involvement in church activities, the speaker felt overwhelmed and needed a break.“I just need time for myself.”33:14Dec 18, 2024
- Questioning Biblical AccuracyThe speaker reflects on their journey of questioning the literal truth of the Bible.“I couldn’t believe the Bible was like accurate and truthful.”39:48Dec 18, 2024
- Fear of Losing CommunityThe fear of losing community when leaving religion is a common experience.“Losing my religion was one of the hardest things.”52:30Dec 18, 2024
- Questioning BeliefsIt's okay to question your beliefs and have discussions around them.“It's okay to question things.”54:13Dec 18, 2024





