The Debate Was Rigged From the Start
Ask about Ex-Homeschoolers Club
Episode Description
Tune in every Friday for new episodes of Ex-Homeschoolers Club!
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- in the New Testament class, there was this one class where he started the class saying like, okay,
- we're going to split up into two halves of the room. If if you think that secular music is sinful, go on this
- side. If you think it's not sinful, go on this side and then we'll debate. So we did all this. It took the whole
- class. I at the end he's like, well, actually it is sinful. So that's it. Bye. And I was just like,
- are you kidding me? Like and his example that he played because he played like, you know, gospel music
- and then he played like a an Elvis song. Okay, so it's sinful to listen to Elvis.
- Like give me a break.
Brief Summary
A New Testament teacher staged a class debate on secular music, then declared it sinful after students spent the whole class arguing both sides.
Key points
- A Debate With a Predetermined Ending. The class splits into two sides to debate whether secular music is sinful. After taking the whole class, the teacher announces that it is sinful and ends the discussion.
- Elvis as Evidence. The teacher plays gospel music and an Elvis song as examples, prompting the speaker to question the conclusion.





